March 9, 2007
Wikipedia Fights Bogus Credentials
When word first leaked that Essjay -- a Wikipedia administrator who claimed to be a tenured professor of religion -- was in fact a 24-year-old without a doctorate, the chief Wikipedian, Jimmy Wales, was quick to defend the beleaguered editor (The Chronicle, March 2).
But now Mr. Wales has changed his tune somewhat. As he told the Associated Press yesterday, Wikipedia will now require contributors who claim lofty credentials to identify themselves instead of hiding behind pseudonyms.
Mr. Wales says that he is still an "anti-credentialist," and that he has no intention of blocking anonymous posters from the site. But the new policy should keep editors like Essjay from inflating their resumes and damaging the site's credibility. (Mr. Wales had proposed the policy change two years ago, but the plan only picked up steam after the recent scandal.)
Taking a stand against pseudonymous puffery seems like a good idea for the site: If academic credentials really are irrelevant to Wikipedia readers, as Mr. Wales suggests, then there is no reason to let anonymous scribes use their biographies (real or fake) to garner respect.
Besides, it's good to know that if any future editors adopt the motto once posted prominently on Essjay's user-talk page -- lux et veritas -- they will have to take the "veritas" part a bit more seriously. --Brock Read
Comments
Commenting is closed for this article.
Previous: 'The Hammer's Coming'
Next: Coming to Terms With Creative Commons
Considering that “lux et veritas” is the motto of Yale University, I would say that Essjay was taking on quite a bit of “puffery” for himself. As a graduate of the Divinity School there, and as a PhD candidate myself, I resent any fake credential. That doesn’t mean that someone doesn’t know something. But why fake credentials if you have the knowledge?
— Elizabeth Cawns Mar 12, 02:39 PM #