The Chronicle of Higher Education
News Blog
In the Comments

"[I] don’t see many job or grad school applications from University of Waikato, but I’ll sure not trust a transcript or diploma from that institution ... who knows what it might mean?” --perplexed

Neo-Nazi Gets University to Pull Master's Thesis on His Views

Recent Posts

Hurricane Ike Caused $710-Million in Damage to University in Texas, Official Says

Higher-Education Groups Want to Watch Over IRS's Questionnaire for Colleges

U. of Missouri Says Classroom Photo of Obama Violates Ban on Political Advocacy

Georgia Proposes Merging Technical Colleges

Bus Carrying Thai Students and Faculty Members Crashes, Killing at Least 21


Most Commented This Month

Palin Attended 4 Colleges in 5 Years to Earn Diploma | 206

Priest Charged With Dealing Drugs out of U. of Illinois Student Center | 56

University Disciplines 4 Students for Hanging Effigy of Barack Obama | 53

Southern Cal Deletes Muslim Scripture From Web Site Following Complaint | 44

Cutthroat Competition for Textbook Sales Pits UMass Faculty Members Against Bookstore | 42

By Category

Athletics
Community Colleges
Government & Politics
Information Technology
International
Money & Management
Northern Illinois
Research & Books
Short Subjects
Students
The Faculty

Blog Archives

Search

Keep Up to Date

Daily news blog: RSS  / Atom

Daily news reported by The Chronicle: RSS

Contact us

April 1, 2008

Judge Sides With 'New England Journal of Medicine' in Peer-Review Dispute

A federal judge in Boston has denied a motion by the pharmaceutical company Pfizer to compel The New England Journal of Medicine to hand over confidential peer reviews and editors’ notes. The decision comes a few weeks after another judge agreed with two other medical journals that they need not reveal their confidential information.

The motions to compel, had they been allowed, would have jeopardized the peer-review process, according to several journal editors. Pfizer requested the documents as part of its defense in a product-liability case involving the arthritis drugs Bextra and Celebrex.

Unlike the other judge’s decision, Magistrate Judge Leo T. Sorokin’s decision found the information sought by Pfizer to be “relevant” but also limited in “probative value.” He also said that the journal should receive protection similar to that enjoyed by journalists. —Lila Guterman

Posted on Tuesday April 1, 2008 | Permalink |