The Chronicle of Higher Education
News Blog
In the Comments

"Some college administrators seem so distracted with fund raising, academic infighting, and community initiatives that they set up their emergency communications departments very poorly. Training is poor to nonexistent, secretaries are pressed into service with tremendous responsibilities for running 'notification systems' 24/7 and on weekends because no one else knows how to do it and the administration won’t pay for additional staff. Procedures are seat-of-the-pants and dependent on HIPPO (highest paid person’s opinion), except when something like Virginia Tech happens and there is some sort of scramble to do something different." --Donna

Most Colleges Avoid Risk Management, Report Says

Recent Posts

Jill Biden Shines a Global Spotlight on American Community Colleges

Connecticut Public Colleges Lose 200 Professors to Early Retirement

U. of Georgia Paid 2 Fraternities $2.4-Million to Relocate, Contracts Show

New Allegations in Admissions Controversy at U. of Illinois Suggest Ex-Provost Played a Role

Sonoma State U. Foundation May Lose $350,000 on Loan to Former Board Member


Most Commented This Month

College Suspends Student for Working in Gay Pornography | 58

President Obama's Visit to Notre Dame Carries Barely a Hint of Controversy That Preceded It | 58

Drug Sting Nabs 21 Students at U. of Illinois | 57

Faculty Members and Union Protest Staff Layoffs at Temple U. as 'Cruel' | 57

North Dakota Board's Vote Puts 'Fighting Sioux' Mascot on Thinner Ice | 57

By Category

Athletics
Community Colleges
Government & Politics
Information Technology
International
Money & Management
Northern Illinois
Research & Books
Short Subjects
Students
The Faculty

Blog Archives

Search

Keep Up to Date

Daily news blog: RSS  / Atom

Daily news reported by The Chronicle: RSS

Contact us

April 1, 2008

Judge Sides With 'New England Journal of Medicine' in Peer-Review Dispute

A federal judge in Boston has denied a motion by the pharmaceutical company Pfizer to compel The New England Journal of Medicine to hand over confidential peer reviews and editors’ notes. The decision comes a few weeks after another judge agreed with two other medical journals that they need not reveal their confidential information.

The motions to compel, had they been allowed, would have jeopardized the peer-review process, according to several journal editors. Pfizer requested the documents as part of its defense in a product-liability case involving the arthritis drugs Bextra and Celebrex.

Unlike the other judge’s decision, Magistrate Judge Leo T. Sorokin’s decision found the information sought by Pfizer to be “relevant” but also limited in “probative value.” He also said that the journal should receive protection similar to that enjoyed by journalists. —Lila Guterman

Posted on Tuesday April 1, 2008 | Permalink |