The Chronicle of Higher Education
News Blog
In the Comments

"Many, many years ago one of my English TA officemates noticed that a student wrote 'writhing' instead of 'writing.' We spent the rest of the afternoon inserting 'writhing' into textbook titles ('Writhing with a Purpose') and other phrases like 'technical writhing.' My favorite: 'writhing across the curriculum.'” --peg

Herding the 'Escape Goats': Contest Sends Up Epidemic of Student Howlers

Recent Posts

College of William and Mary Hires Interim Chief as President

Cuomo Reported to Be Planning New Student-Loan Lawsuit and Agreements

Southern Cal Deletes Muslim Scripture From Web Site Following Complaint

Palin Attended 4 Colleges in 5 Years to Earn Diploma

California Budget Impasse Delays Grants for Community-College Students


Most Commented This Month

Palin Attended 4 Colleges in 5 Years to Earn Diploma | 147

Professor Suspects UCLA Is Illegally Using Race in Admissions Decisions | 40

Cutthroat Competition for Textbook Sales Pits UMass Faculty Members Against Bookstore | 36

British Publisher Will Release Controversial Novel About Muhammad's Bride | 17

Sami Al-Arian Is Out of Jail for First Time in 5 Years | 17

By Category

Athletics
Community Colleges
Government & Politics
Information Technology
International
Money & Management
Northern Illinois
Research & Books
Short Subjects
Students
The Faculty

Blog Archives

Search

Keep Up to Date

Daily news blog: RSS  / Atom

Daily news reported by The Chronicle: RSS

Contact us

June 11, 2007

2 Authors Assail Paper's Finding on Concussions and College Athletes

Two out of five of the authors of an influential medical article on concussions among professional football players say that their co-authors added a conclusion, without their knowledge, that “it might be safe” for high-school and college players to return to games in which they had suffered the brain-joggling injuries, The New York Times reported on Sunday.

The paper, commissioned by the National Football League and published in the journal Neurosurgery in 2005, recommended that doctors for high-school and college athletes “keep an open mind” about the issue, and it has influenced the care of those players ever since. One of the two critical authors said the conclusion had been added at a final stage of proof, when authors do not expect to find their colleagues making major changes.

The paper’s two lead authors said they had added the controversial conclusion — at the behest of peer reviewers who sought to broaden the article’s scope beyond professional players, they said — and stood by their findings. They also said they were not to blame if their findings, intended only to “stimulate interest,” were misinterpreted as guidelines.

An article published today in The Chronicle describes a recent rise in the number of concussions in college sports, particularly among female athletes, in what one university’s athletics trainer called “a hidden epidemic.” —Andrew Mytelka

Posted on Monday June 11, 2007 | Permalink |