The Chronicle of Higher Education
News Blog
In the Comments

"Some college administrators seem so distracted with fund raising, academic infighting, and community initiatives that they set up their emergency communications departments very poorly. Training is poor to nonexistent, secretaries are pressed into service with tremendous responsibilities for running 'notification systems' 24/7 and on weekends because no one else knows how to do it and the administration won’t pay for additional staff. Procedures are seat-of-the-pants and dependent on HIPPO (highest paid person’s opinion), except when something like Virginia Tech happens and there is some sort of scramble to do something different." --Donna

Most Colleges Avoid Risk Management, Report Says

Recent Posts

Jill Biden Shines a Global Spotlight on American Community Colleges

Connecticut Public Colleges Lose 200 Professors to Early Retirement

U. of Georgia Paid 2 Fraternities $2.4-Million to Relocate, Contracts Show

New Allegations in Admissions Controversy at U. of Illinois Suggest Ex-Provost Played a Role

Sonoma State U. Foundation May Lose $350,000 on Loan to Former Board Member


Most Commented This Month

College Suspends Student for Working in Gay Pornography | 58

President Obama's Visit to Notre Dame Carries Barely a Hint of Controversy That Preceded It | 58

Drug Sting Nabs 21 Students at U. of Illinois | 57

Faculty Members and Union Protest Staff Layoffs at Temple U. as 'Cruel' | 57

North Dakota Board's Vote Puts 'Fighting Sioux' Mascot on Thinner Ice | 57

By Category

Athletics
Community Colleges
Government & Politics
Information Technology
International
Money & Management
Northern Illinois
Research & Books
Short Subjects
Students
The Faculty

Blog Archives

Search

Keep Up to Date

Daily news blog: RSS  / Atom

Daily news reported by The Chronicle: RSS

Contact us

April 20, 2007

Authors of Controversial Iraq Study Release Raw Data Selectively

Under fire from critics, researchers from the Johns Hopkins University and elsewhere have released selected bits of data from a much-discussed study of how many Iraqis have died since the 2003 American invasion.

In an article published in October 2006 in The Lancet, the British medical journal, a team led by Gilbert Burnham of Hopkins estimated that there were 650,000 more Iraqi deaths after the invasion than would have been expected based on conditions before the war. The study was conducted by sending interviewers to neighborhoods to canvas 1,849 households (The Chronicle, October 20, 2006), and it followed up on a 2004 study.

At the time of the publication, the Johns Hopkins group did not disclose the identity of the interviewers or the neighborhoods surveyed because their Iraqi collaborators had asked them to withhold the data to protect the interviewers, Dr. Burnham said on his Web site.

Now that six months have passed, the team announced that it would release some data, but it is still not identifying the neighborhoods involved in the study. And it will send data only “to recognized academic institutions or scientific groups with biostatistical and epidemiological analytic capacity.” Another requirement is that the information go only to groups “without publicly stated views that would cause doubt about their objectivity in analyzing the data.”

Science magazine reports that the Johns Hopkins team has refused to send the data to at least one researcher and that several scientists are upset about the restrictions, which they say make it impossible to verify the study’s conclusions. —Richard Monastersky

Posted on Friday April 20, 2007 | Permalink |