Have you had success with dried-up, unused plates that you revived by moistening?
No, I've just managed to save bacteria from them. I have never tried to used old dried up agar. I
have used out of date ingredients in LB broth before, though, and that was fine.
I am wondering if the drying out will have affected the nutrients in the agar. I know for sure that you're not supposed to re-autoclave media (though people do it) so I am pretty sure that reconstituting and reautoclaving dried up agar is not the best thing in the world. However, if you're just looking for something to grow and aren't all that concerned about the results, then you might be OK doing it.