I don't think you can really say that any one thing hurts your chances unless you happen to come off as arrogant or get really nervous during interviews. Otherwise, its really just a matter of whether your experience matches the school. Do you apply for jobs at R1s and not have enough publications? Or, apply to teaching oriented colleges and not give enough evidence of great teaching? Think along the lines of which sort of institution you'd most like to be at, and try to see how you fit that, and can improve the fit.
Thanks.....I don't apply to R1....I am not interested in that...only teaching. I have won awards for teaching and I have a lot of evidence of successful teaching. I don't believe that I come off arrogant, but my ability to sense this might not be that acute.....
This makes it sound as if you have no research credentials, and/or your application packet makes it clear that you have no interest in doing ongoing research. As other threads indicate, this will NOT get you a job in a four-year college. Even schools that prioritize teaching skills want their faculty to remain current in the field, as witnessed by some research.
