Jonesey, you forgot Robbie Williams, a total no-talent image person. The English have a difficult time chruning out raw, brazen in-your-face talent. Or is that just an American thing?
For a week now I have been trying to forget this post, but I take popular music very seriously (occupational hazard). The suggestion that UK popular music is about image while US popular music is about raw talent is, quite simply, blowing my mind. I won't bother defending the sheer entertainment value of Robbie Williams, but 'a difficult time churning out raw, brazen in-your-face talent'? You mean like the Beatles? The Rolling Stones? Dusty Springfield? The Who? Small Faces? The Clash? The Smiths? Pulp? Even if you consider the contemporary charts, the UK charts tend to be more varied and interesting (though both are pretty awful). I would certainly include Amy Winehouse, Muse and Richard Hawley in the category of raw talent. When people ask me why I moved to Britain, I often say because 1 in 7 households owns the Best of the Beautiful South. I half mean it! There may be reasons to pick on the British, but music is not one of them.
But, then, I love mushy peas and feel full of joy when I hear a Take That singalong.