Yes, I agree that graduate advisers can have a detrimental or beneficial effect on the mental health of a graduate student, especially a doctoral student. My first adviser had a very negative effect, but I have a very strong self-image and would not allow his negativity to cloud my judgment of my abilities. My 2nd adviser ( I was able to excuse the first one) was very positive, encouraging and provided the support that I needed to succeed. Advisers should be helpful as guides toward a common goal. They should not attempt to throw roadblocks as a cruel initiation into the world of academia. Thank goodness for professionals in our field that seek to assist graduate students in reaching their potential. There are some advisers that are destructive and arrogant and should not be allowed to mentor graduate students.
JOIN THE DEBATE Be sure to include your name and affiliation. Legitimate requests for anonymity will be honored. Submissions may be condensed or edited for clarity.
| ||||||||
previous response
Copyright © 1998 by The Chronicle of Higher Education