• Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Previous

Next

You Can Summarize Your Thesis in a Tweet, but Should You?

January 13, 2012, 3:55 pm

Thesis ResearchCall it the ultimate exercise in brevity. Or the digital equivalent of an academic elevator pitch.

Just don’t call it simple.

Students across the world are using the Twitter hashtag #tweetyourthesis to shrink their academic thesis work down to single 140-character posts. The concept isn’t new: Boston University held a #BUthesis contest in April 2010, and #TweCon, a Twitter conference, has happened twice. But this week, the thesis-shrinking idea went viral and #tweetyourthesis sparked a debate among academics on Twitter about the social network’s potential for sharpening an idea.

Susan Greenberg, a senior lecturer in English and creative writing at the University of Roehampton, in London, first used the #tweetyourthesis hashtag on Wednesday. She said the idea was hatched over dinner with some research students from University College London, where she is a part-time doctoral student in the department of information studies. She boiled down her own work, tentatively titled “Editing and Meaning,” into the following tongue-in-cheek tweet: “Editors are god, except when they are all sacked.” She wrote that her thesis explored the question, “How do we assess invisible work like editing?”

Before anyone else could chime in with their own miniaturized thesis topics, users began asking the question that helped propel #tweetyourthesis worldwide: What does it mean if a student can condense an idea for such a long project into 140 characters?

“If u can’t summarise ur research in a tweet u need to do a lot more work on ur question,” wrote Claire Warwick, a professor of digital humanities and head of the department of information studies at University College London.

@david_colqhoun cautioned that such a rule might not apply to long-winded science topics, and @shanemuk was even more critical: “If you CAN summarise your research in a tweet, you’re not working hard enough or on important qs!” he wrote.

@ernestopriego suggested the thesis-shrinking exercise could be useful in the real world: “Think of #tweetyourthesis thus: funder/head of school/publisher in the elevator with you. You have one minute. How do you pitch your work?” he asked.

For her part, Ms. Greenberg said she appreciates the emerging debate, and thinks there are skills to be gained from the discipline of having to communicate quickly. She added that Twitter’s social nature injects a little humor into the grueling slog that some thesis writers experience.

“Writing a thesis can be a very lonely activity, so it can be nice to have an area of sharing,” she said.

And though #tweetyourthesis has grown quickly since users around the world began sharing it, Ms. Greenberg noted with a laugh that something familiar has kept her from tracking its every move.

“I wasn’t monitoring this minute-by-minute, because I was busy working on my thesis,” she said.

Herewith, a sample of #tweetyourthesis topics:


What do you think of #tweetyourthesis? Let us know in the comments.

[Creative Commons licensed Flickr photo by bjornmensbear]

This entry was posted in Research, Social Networking. Bookmark the permalink.

  • Print
  • Comment
  • larryc

    #tweetyourthesis: Academics will over-analyze a plate of beans.

    Ooops, I was tweeting the thesis of this article by accident! (And stealing a Metafilter meme.)

  • http://twitter.com/InesMergel Ines Mergel

    Also, check out the #MyResearch hashtag (https://twitter.com/#!/search?q=%23MyResearch) that was started by @raulpacheco:twitter  and has evolved into a nice collaboration network over the weekend. It was visualized by @marcsmith:twitter: https://nodexlgraphgallery.org/Pages/Graph.aspx?graphID=344

  • mbelvadi

    This reminds me a bit of the 24/7 Lectures at the Ignobel Prize ceremonies.  Serious, peer-reviewed-published research summarized in 24 seconds, then again with just 7 words.  All in fun, and doesn’t detract from the value of the research.  So much for it not applying to science!

  • judithryan43

    The elevator pitch is harder than the tweet because in the elevator, you have less time to think.

  • gideonburton

    We coined the term “tweethis” in my writing course last June, and found that a tweet-sized thesis statement proved very useful both for refining and for sharing one’s argument. When my students each contributed a chapter to an eBook based on their literary blogging, we used their “tweethis statements” as subtitles very effectively (see them listed in the table of contents or download the eBook from here: http://thedigitalwriter.blogspot.com/p/ebook.html). When students are thinking in terms of sharing their thoughts concisely and publicly, even early in their writing process, it not only helps them refine their thinking, but it gives energy and authenticity to the process.

  • katisumas

    Tweetyourthesis: Einstein couldn’t have tweeted his thesis.

  • rpacheco

    Thanks, @twitter-15659409:disqus for sharing the #MyResearch hashtag, and to @marcsmith:disqus for beautiful visualization. I have written an admittedly-early-stage draft of how #MyResearch came to be, and here is the link for everyone to peruse. 
    http://www.raulpacheco.org/2012/01/knowledge-translation-mobilization-and-the-myresearch-hashtag/

  • Heather Weaver

    Hi!

    My name is Heather and I work for Worth Ave. Group. We’re
    currently holding a contest for K-12 teachers to win grants for their schools,
    and iPads or iPods for their classrooms. If you’re interested in participating,
    feel free to email me or visit the link I’ve posted below.

    Have a great day!

    http://www.worthavegroup.com/giveaway/

    voteforteachers@worthavegroup.com 

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=11704969 Drew Jaramillo

    Tweet your thesis? Perhaps I need one first. 

  • swapnakoshy

    Tried this at the Learning in Higher Education Conference last May in Greece. Many found it challenging but commented that it clarified the research question.
      
    Also, a good exercise to teach summarising skills.
    We may soon be reporting to bosses in tweets … so pick up the skill.

    However, tweeting your thesis could spawn palgiarism and copyright issues.

  • http://twitter.com/marc_smith Marc Smith

    https://nodexlgraphgallery.org/Pages/Graph.aspx?graphID=352

    This is a map of the connections among the Twitter users who recently tweeted the word tweetyourthesis when queried on January 17, 2012, scaled by numbers of followers (with outliers thresholded). Connections created when users reply, mention or follow one another. The data set starts on 1/11/2012 22:43 and ends on 1/16/2012 14:20 UTC. Green lines are “follows” relationships, blue lines are “reply” or “mentions” relationships.Layout created with the “Group Layout” feature of NodeXL which tiles bounded regions for each cluster. Clusters calculated by the Clauset-Newman-Moore algorithm are also encoded by color.

    A larger version of the image is here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/marc_smith/6716429175/sizes/l/

    Betweenness Centrality is defined here:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centrality#Betweenness_centrality

    Clauset-Newman-Moore algorithm is defined here:
    http://pre.aps.org/abstract/PRE/v70/i6/e066111

    Top most between users:
    @ernestopriego
    @thesiswhisperer
    @gdnhighered
    @melissaterras
    @lseimpactblog
    @dancohen
    @adelinekoh
    @annewelsh
    @qui_oui
    @wiredcampus

    Top word pairs by frequency:
    those, enterprising
    enterprising, folks
    spearheading, #tweetyourthesis
    more, details
    #tweetyourthesis, here
    want, #tweetyourthesis
    main, question
    phd, seeks
    one, tweet

    Graph Type: Directed
    Vertices: 750
    Unique Edges: 7164
    Edges With Duplicates: 1246
    Total Edges: 8410
    Self-Loops: 675
    Connected Components: 18
    Single-Vertex Connected Components: 16
    Maximum Vertices in a Connected Component: 732
    Maximum Edges in a Connected Component: 8388
    Maximum Geodesic Distance (Diameter): 9
    Average Geodesic Distance: 3.056572
    Graph Density: 0.012744103
    Modularity: 0.331255
    NodeXL Version: 1.0.1.196

    More NodeXL network visualizations are here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/marc_smith/sets/72157622437066929/

    and here:

    http://www.nodexlgraphgallery.org/Pages/Default.aspx

    A gallery of NodeXL network data sets is available here: http://nodexlgraphgallery.org/Pages/Default.aspx?search=twitter

    NodeXL is free and open and available from http://www.codeplex.com/nodexl

    NodeXL is developed by the Social Media Research Foundation (http://www.smrfoundation.org) – which is dedicated to open tools, open data, and open scholarship.

    Donations to support NodeXL are welcome through PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=J5AERGAAN552S

    The book, Analyzing social media networks with NodeXL: Insights from a connected world, is available from Morgan Kaufmann and from Amazon.

    http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0123822297?ie=utf8&tag=conneactio-20&linkcode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeasin=0123822297