• Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Previous

Next

Learn About Robots From Stanford Professors, Free of Charge

November 19, 2011, 12:23 pm

This fall Stanford University took a step forward in the open-education movement by offering three free online courses, following in the footsteps of several other elite colleges like Yale University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

The three classes being offered—”Machine Learning,” “Introduction to Artificial Intelligence,” and “Introduction to Databases“—are among some of the university’s most popular computer-science courses, according to a blog post on the Open Culture Web site. Enrollment figures for the courses seemingly back up this claim: Andrew Ng, the professor for the machine-learning course, has approximately 94,000 students enrolled in his class alone, he told The Chronicle.

Students in the class includes high schoolers, grandmothers, and soldiers fighting in Afghanistan. “Teaching tens of thousands of students at a time is a very gratifying experience,” he said.

These online courses are particularly noteworthy because they go beyond taped lectures, which the university offers through its iTunes U and YouTube services. Building off an idea developed by Stanford’s Daphne Koller, a computer-science professor, students in the courses, offered this fall, skip the traditional long lecture. Instead, they progress at their own pace using short, interactive video lectures that are punctuated every five to eight minutes with questions to make sure the student grasps the concept before continuing to the next idea.

It’s a lot like the way Mr. Ng teaches his students in the physical classroom, but in some ways the online medium is even more interactive, he says. “My experience as an instructor is that when I ask a question in class, 20 percent of the students are on Facebook, 50 percent are still scribbling away at their notes, and the one smarty pants in the front row answers the question.” Online, all the students answer the questions and gets automated feedback on their work.

It’s not the professor answering the students, though; it’s the computer. The professors do not actually interact with the students. The software does provide them with automated feedback, which Mr. Ng says will often pick up on a student’s specific error. There are also Q&A forums where the students can chat with each other.

The free classes, while they do offer the same information taught to students enrolled at the university, don’t come with any course credit toward a Stanford degree. But students are expected to keep up with readings and assignments, Sebastian Thrun, the professor  who runs the artificial-intelligence course, said in an article about the classes on Stanford’s Web site. And students should expect to spend at least 12 hours a week on his course, he said.

Classes are offered as part of the Stanford Engineering Everywhere initiative, which is financed by venture capital firm Sequoia Capital.

This entry was posted in Computer Science, Distance Education, Open Access. Bookmark the permalink.

  • Print
  • Comment
  • http://twitter.com/jamesprabhakar James Prabhakar GSC

    Though these courses do  not earn any course credit, it would certainly help students who would like to add their learning from the educational stuff from Stanford University.

  • glasspen

    I am taking the Intro to Databases class, along with several of my colleagues at work.  First time trying anything like this…very pleased with the information, exercises, etc.  Haven’t been able to put in as much time as I’d like (full time job, etc.) but don’t need the grade and have learned a lot as it is. Thanks to Stanford and MIT and other institutions pioneering this type of instruction.

  • cdamic

    A wonderful idea for retirees who want to do something they didn’t get to do in their career. 

  • betterschool

    The double standards and hypocrisy in higher education standards and practices are incomprehensible. Professionals having three decade’s of experience in online education agree that the features of the learning platform, the design of the curriculum, the pedagogical approach, and the skills of the instructor all modulate the numbers that represent the range of acceptable class sizes. While professionals disagree on those numbers, the ranges are probably between 10 and 35 students. (Mature online programs, for example, require instructors to respond to student inquiries in 24 hours or less.) Calling an aggregation of 94,000 students “online education” is professionally irresponsible. I took one of these online “courses” recently and paid the fees charged to have a TA give me approximately 45 seconds of his time (assuming that that his response wasn’t bot generated). The curriculum was well thought out if you didn’t diverge from the designer’s expectations but no one would mistake anything going on for teaching. This is an Internet age equivalent to a U.S. Postal Services correspondence course. I’m pleased to see these kinds of programs but we need to get our standards and terminology straight. If a for-profit or some other unfavored institutional type dared to enroll 100 students in an online class, the response would be much different. And let’s not forget, these courses are “free” only to the students. Taxpayers underwrite elite private colleges and universities in the range of $25,000 to $45,000 per student per year with no say in the matter.

  • Guest

    In the humanities, this is what we call “publishing” — you compose some work that applies your scholarly insight to a topic of interest to people anywhere and everywhere. It’s great to share your work with the rest of the world. But it isn’t teaching.

  • http://twitter.com/furrier John Furrier

    I love this direction… I’m spinning up a not for profit called SiliconACADEMY to do the same for big data and data science and entrepreneurship for geeks

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike-Dalton/100001443641208 Mike Dalton

    Thank you betterschool.  While I applaud the willingness to share information, this is not an on-line course.  I didn’t realize taxpayers had to support it though.  That makes it even less attractive.  Teaching is hard work.  I have a hard enough time with 20 or 50 students.  94,000?  The Internet is a wonderful thing, but this article and schools like the University of Pheonix mark a decline in education.

  • betterschool

    I don’t mean to get into a discussion over type of control but you might want to learn more about the University of Phoenix. What I will say does not apply to all for-profits — or even most of them — but Phoenix was a pioneer in online pedagogy for adults and still is. The last time I saw stats, Phoenix’ average online class size was less than 16 and they capped it at 18-20. They also insisted that every professor provide substantive responses to student inquiries within 24 hours. Again, I’m glad to see the Stanford project but public awareness of the details for higher education is poor and what is there is somewhat romanticized. I live in some of these details and I see the greatest abuses committed bu the elites and big name schools because they lack the ability to examine themselves absent their rhetoric of greatness. All schools that are in a position to accept only the best and brightest — and wealthiest — can be “great.” On the other hand, it takes real talent to turn an undereducated, underemployed, socially and economically disadvantaged 19 year-old single parent into a self-confident nurse who is now vertically mobile, pays taxes, and works along side other health care professionals. The educators who do these kinds of things deserve our highest praise. Instead, we praise those who add much less value teaching those whose genetic traits and socials advantages predisposition them to learn easily and well.

  • blues

    good post and good idea.

  • http://twitter.com/rivenhomewood rivenhomewood

    I find it very interesting that people who haven’t taken any of these courses express such strong opinions about them. I tried two of them, and found both of them extremely rigorous and demanding. 

    I’ve taken a number of online classes in the past. Generally they leave
    me feeling like I’ve paid a fee in order to have access to a website and
    a discussion forum. These made me feel like I was enrolled in a class

    My son is taking the Machine Intelligence course, loves it, and expects to complete it this month. He feels it’s the best-designed online class he’s ever seen, and loves both the video format and the programming assignments. I registered for the Database class, but despite having had a similar class about 20 years ago I found the material and pace too much for me. I lasted through the first three units of the Artificial Intelligence class, loved the format – short videos with constant feedback – but found my lack of background in probability to be a serious problem. Bayes Law eventually did me in, tho I hope they will still have the course modules up so I can continue over Christmas break.

    Perhaps most amazingly, when I tweeted about my problems with the Database class, I received a tweet right back from the instructor. She urged me to hang in there, because the assignments would become more practical as we went along. She had about 75 thousand students in this class, yet she either took the time to reply or had set up specific responses that could be sent out as needed..

    Stanford is planning to offer 11 courses this way in the spring. My son’s planning to take the one on cryptography. I’m still trying to decide on mine.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mia-Green/100002891811832 Mia Green

    Cool, it’s absolutely free of charge to students and educators around the world. Hope more courses will be available in the future.

    Mia @ http://textbooks.org/

  • http://www.facebook.com/thkro Thomas Kröll

    Tried to do the Database classes but could not finish due to work commitments. Definitely a great concept and would like to try do another course again. Would be nice to add Standford University education to my CV even if there is no certification.

    Thomas @ http://www.dcc.edu.za/