• Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Previous

Next

Minnesota Court Upholds University’s Right to Discipline Student Over Facebook Comments

July 11, 2011, 11:09 pm

The Minnesota Court of Appeals has upheld the University of Minnesota’s right to discipline a student in a mortuary-sciences class over comments she posted on Facebook, Minnesota Public Radio reported. One comment referred to stabbing someone. Others referred to cadavers used in an embalming lab in a way that upset the families of anatomy-bequest donors. The student, Amanda Tatro, had argued that the university had no authority to discipline her for off-campus activities. In an opinion issued today, however, the court said that the university had not violated Ms. Tatro’s rights by holding her accountable to the program’s rules requiring respect and professionalism, and by taking seriously any potential threats.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

  • Print
  • Comment
  • Geoz32

    I wonder what this limit on speech is based on.  If it were me deciding the college would have to show that harm would be done to the college because of this speech.  (cadavers would not be donated, etc.).  Otherwise, if it is about her professionalism, then she ought to get her grade modified appropriately, not disciplined.

  • Socratease2

    I don’t think this a free speech issue, she isn’t being disciplined for exercising her first ammendment rights nor is she being disciplined for “off campus activities” she is being called out for behavior on campus (stabbing and god knows what else) and that is completely different. She is an idiot for posting what she did seeing as it was clearly a major breach of professional ethics. The courts did right. What is it about facebook that people think they can publicly admit to crimes with no consequence. Dumb and dumber.

  • http://twitter.com/Faiyla Youssef Cherif

    Creepy :D