• Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Previous

Next

Another Court Turns Deaf Ear to Professor’s Tirade Over Parking Ticket

December 20, 2011, 5:44 pm

A federal appeals court has rejected a professor’s lawsuit against the University of New Hampshire that, after nearly three years of litigation, has done little but highlight his ill-advised actions in the university’s department of biochemistry and molecular biology.

The case stems from what the court described as an “expletive-laden tirade” by John Collins, a tenured associate professor and chair of the department, after his car was ticketed on the campus in June 2007 and he suspected a colleague had reported his illegally parked car to the authorities. In his tirade, Mr. Collins threatened to kill the colleague. He also “kicked a large trash can,” the court said.

Mr. Collins ended up being stripped of his chairmanship and temporarily put on paid leave and banned from the campus. He also faced criminal charges of stalking and disorderly conduct, but a jury acquitted him in late 2007.

Mr. Collins later sued the university, its provost, and a police officer, accusing them of false arrest, defamation, and violation of his due-process rights. A federal district court ruled summarily against him in 2010, and on Tuesday a unanimous three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit affirmed the lower court’s decision. Mr. Collins continues to serve on the department’s faculty.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

  • Print
  • Comment
  • happyprof

    Sounds like this guy must have been a real piece of work as a chairman.  The worst thing for the department will be that this guy can stick around because of tenure, and must stick around because no one else would even consider hiring such a documented hot-head.  He will no doubt ruin the workplace for everyone else in his department.

  • rsgassle

    Moral turpitude?

  • wclibrary

    Higher ed faculty = a group defined by their sharing both advanced degrees and a grievance over parking.

  • chuckkle

    Why does this make me think of frequent CHE blog responder “livefreeordie2″?

  • 22259152

    Due Process?  He got a ticket for not following the rules.  He thinks his due process rights were violated?  Does anybody else think his due process rights were violated?

  • dank48

    And I thought “Academically Adrift” was about the students. . . .

  • pokerphd

    Neat. I get to post for the second time today that we are once again reminded how often “the empty vessel makes the greatest sound.”

  • not4nothin

    Poor Dr. Collins, at the BMB Department Holiday Party, standing under the mistletoe and waiting – waiting – waiting…
    That evening, at the stroke of midnight, John is visited by the first of three ghosts…

  • superdude

    I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: faculty will complain about parking until they are able to park IN their offices.  Then they’ll complain that their offices are too small.

  • dank48

    Just nitpicking here, but I’d say “a jaundiced eye” would be more appropriate than “a deaf ear.” The court could hear him just fine. It just didn’t like what it heard any more than it liked what it saw.

  • MChag12

    Yes to both, and for good reason.  My office IS too small, and as for parking, I am astonished that the State decided to make up their deficits not only through underpaying faculty and staff, but making us all pay A LOT for parking every year. In what other profession does the employees pay for coming to work?   Yes, greasy spaghetti issues, but sometimes cigars need to be recognized.  He is probably very mild mannered and considerate otherwise!  

  • ehyouadvisor

    It is four apparitions that visit…

  • theart

    I guess it depends on how you define the parking ticket “process”.  Some of the more narcissistic faculty already believe that their jobs involve being paid to berate people.  Thus in his mind, bartering a tantrum instead of cash constituted payment.

  • greeneyeshade

    I’ve been to UNH a few times.  The campus is practically surrounded by undeveloped land.  That they have a parking problem seems odd, but then again every university has parking problems.  Goes with the territory (or lack thereof).

  • pokerphd

    Budgets being what they are–and UNH parking extremely limited–it is three…

  • manoflamancha

    All the big issues are discussed on these pages: sex for the undergrads, sports for the grad students, and of course, parking for the faculty. Was this taken from Clark Kerr at Berkeley?

  • dank48

    You mean grad students are playing sports these days? What is the world coming to?