• Monday, May 28, 2012

Previous

Next

Surprised by Technology?

February 15, 2012, 12:00 pm

We received some interesting answers to last week’s “Open Thread” question, which asked “What Are Your Favorite Technologies in the Classroom?” Here at ProfHacker, we try to ground our conversations in actual experience: with teaching, with research, with health and fitness, with many different aspects of academic life. We believe in experimentation and learning from our mistakes as well as our successes.

This week, I’d like to revisit the issue of technology with a slightly different question than last week’s. Please use the comments below to share when you were surprised (either positively or negatively) by technology in an academic context. Often our choices are constrained by the technology made available by the institutions where we work, and sometimes we might be pleasantly surprised by something we initially approached with dread. On the other hand, sometimes we have high hopes for a new software application or hardware device, only to be disappointed that it doesn’t live up to our idea of its potential.

When you have been surprised by technology in an academic context? Please share in the comments.

[Creative Commons-licensed flickr photo "Surprise!" by Michelle Tribe.]

This entry was posted in Hardware, Productivity, Software, Teaching and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

  • Print
  • Comment
  • 11213358

    I teach two undergraduate seminars in which research and writing are key components, and we use no paper (everything is passed back and forth via email or the course web site). I routinely offer to review drafts of papers as long as they’re submitted far enough before the deadline. 

    A few years ago I reminded my students about the offer to review drafts, and after class a young woman came up and asked if she could give me her draft to review. I assumed she meant she would send it to me electronically, but she held up her cell phone and said, “Here it is.” It seems she wrote all of her papers for all her classes on her cell phone, only transferring them to her laptop to format them for final submission! I declined to look at the draft on the cell phone, but asked her to forward it to me as an email attachment.

  • antiutopia

    I’d like to second profmomof1′s comments: I don’t think we take seriously enough the need to invest time and resources to learn to effectively use technology.  Some of our students are surprisingly adept, but some are not — and we have to serve all of them.  My question is always about the ratio of classroom time in teaching the software/technology to learning benefits. Small learning curve with obvious benefits=good technology. 

    I’ve found turnitin.com to be a very useful tool all around, but some features aren’t as good as others.  The originality reports are good.  The grademark function is good. The gradebook is good, but I wish we could leave comments with individual gradebook items and had more options for attendance keeping.  The ETS grammar checker, on the other hand, is almost worthless.  I spend more time deleting wrong comments (flags header information as fragments, doesn’t understand inline citations, mistakes comma splices for run-ons, misidentifies fragments regularly) than I would adding manually the few comments that I choose to keep.  That’s really too bad, as ETS comments include a link to the rule, which is a good feature.

  • http://ProfHacker.com George H. Williams

    Just a friendly editorial reminder that the comments are for readers to share their answers to the above question: When have you been surprised by technology in an academic context?

    If you have a specific experience to share, please do so. Thanks!

  • http://twitter.com/comnting c

     Two things:
    1)  My university’s CMS is a flavor of Sakai.  I’m so used to clunky web interfaces, I’ve moved passed “frustration” to “resignation.”  I was expecting many tasks to be annoying and time consuming.  One of the biggest annoyances is the inability, in most web interfaces, to upload or download multiple files at once; you have to save/upload each file individually.
    But I was surprised that while our CMS does indeed have this kind of web interface, it also allows you to connect to its filespaces as a shared drive.  I could have the CMS space as a file folder on my computer, and just drag and drop all the readings in there at once!  Also, students can upload their essays to their individual boxes, and I can download them all at once organized by folders named with each student’s email ID.  What convenience!  It’s just a reminder that these tools are evolving (if slowly) to respond to user needs.  If you have given up on using IT in the classroom because you found it inadequate before, take another look!

    2) I have students use the CMS forum feature to post a discussion question for each day’s reading, mostly so they come to class prepared with something to talk about.  Sometimes students just post their required question and never look further.  But some classes have really run away with it.  The forum is based on one of the free templates used everywhere on the internet (phpBB, I think), so students are already very familiar with how to use it.  Sometimes they really get into the discussion, going back and forth, using [quote] functions to highlight quotes from the texts and each other’s posts and make some point.  Not only is this a way for the class to extend beyond our three hours a week, it’s great when it comes time to talk about how to structure essays!

  • rothphysix

    In my modest experience as a higher-ed adjunct, I found it vital to poll my students early on as to their preferred way of getting course information and resources online. At College A, students were perfectly happy to use my weebly page for the course, which I found much easier than BlackBoard to integrate assignments, links, etc. for a particular lesson. At College B, students relied on my making full use of Blackboard and its calendar because they could see all their courses at once. I had perhaps vainly thought my personal page superior and hadn’t appreciated how its real and imagined advantages might pale against the advantages of one-stop shopping chez Blackboard (however uninspiring the GUI). Somewhat a cultural thing for the campus, perhaps, and maybe also adjuncts and new faculty should find out what incoming students are being instructed to do at orientation. Peace – JR

  • nicolewyatt

    I have just recently been surprised to discover that there is no straightforward way to use mail merge to generate multiple files. Either I can have individual email messages or one file with each ‘letter’ as a separate file. I am sure there are ways around this, but not obvious or quick ones. I would have thought this sort of feature would be in high demand.

    The context by the way was hoping to set up my grading rubric as a google form, and then download the resulting spreadsheet and use it to generate a pdf with feedback for each student which could be uploaded to our CMS. The emails option won’t do, since the privacy laws where I live prohibit sending grades or other feedback by email.

  • Neha Saini

    Thank you

    Your blog is very informative.
    I will keep updated with same.
    MLM software Noida 

  • The Chronicle of Higher Education
  • 1255 Twenty-Third St, N.W.
  • Washington, D.C. 20037