• Monday, May 28, 2012

Previous

Next

Philanthropy: Doing More With Giving

April 12, 2011, 3:00 pm

Charity Recycling
[This is a guest post by Courtney Danforth, who teaches English at the College of Southern Nevada and tweets as @csdanforth. Courtney previously wrote "Disaster Planning and the Academic Career" for ProfHacker.--@jbj]

You probably already give to charity. Maybe you do Race for the Cure every year, or are a member of your public radio station, or donate blood, or are a scout leader, or make a traditional tithe, or take a shift at the homeless shelter. You could probably give more–most of us could. But this post is about more than charity, because just as ProfHacker does more and does it better with the resources we’ve got, philanthropy is doing more with charity. Charity is about giving (your money, your time, your stuff); philanthropy is about sharing your charitable interests and gathering support for them. What follows are tips and tools for doing more with your giving.

Give Your Money

On giving to charity, “How much do you have to give? What’s the total amount?”, asks Albert Brooks in Defending Your Life (1991). There’s no easy answer, but you could do worse than to follow the ancient practice of tithing–budgeting 10% (of income and/or time) to give to others. Whatever amount you have to give, it will be appreciated and put to good use if you take care in selecting a recipient. Here are some tools for choosing well:

Charity Navigator screenshot

Charity Navigator evaluates charities for organizational efficiency and capacity and lists data gathered from tax forms of charities so that donors can make smart, informed decisions for how best to give money. Profiles include information such as ratio of funds spent on programming vs. administration vs. fundraising, CEO salary, and organizations with related missions.

With FirstGiving, users create individual fundraising pages within the system and encourage others to support the cause and the charity by promoting the page through popular networks. However you use it, you can set up the service to email you (the fundraiser) every time someone donates through your page and use an auto-reply to thank the donor for supporting your cause and to provide any other information you want to share.

Similar to FirstGiving, JustGive is a fundraising service and a tracking service for your giving history. Additionally, Justgive includes charity-discovery and tools to plan your giving.

Bring Light is a for-profit company. Charities pay a service fee for using the service plus a percentage of each donation. You can insure that more of your gift reaches the programs you want to support by giving directly to the charity, but Bring Light and similar companies aren’t all bad since they function as clearinghouse for organizations and offer tracking tools to donors.

Like Bring Light, Xperedon deducts a portion (5%) of donations as fees (and also tax, for Swiss charities). This service operates on a portfolio model; users set up a roster of charities they wish to support, then donate monthly, and Xperedon allocates the monthly gift according to the portfolio. With CardLink, you link your debit or credit card to your Xperedon account and associate your donations to your spending. So, if 30% of your monthly spending goes to restaurants and groceries, then 30% of your charitable gift for that month will be assigned to food- or hunger- related charities. And if 10% of your bill is for hotels, then 10% of your designated monthly charitable gift will go to organizations addressing homelessness. This seems a good way to be more thoughtful about your own spending in relation to world issues.

Kiva screenshot

Kiva is a microfinance program with the goal of alleviating worldwide poverty. It is not exactly a “charity”, in the tax sense of the word; what it gives away is low-interest microloans to help people (81.42% women) start businesses. According to Kiva, safe, affordable access to capital is a key to overcoming poverty.

Kickstarter, like Kiva, is not exactly a charitable organization in the tax sense of the word. Some of the projects in Kickstarter are proposed by charitable organizations, but it is not a function fundamental to the tool/system. Kickstarter manages projects and microinvestors to support creative projects (for example, 1100 other sponsors and I recently funded the “Replacing the ‘N-word’ with ‘Robot’ in Huck Finn” project).
Huck/Robot

DonorsChoose, operating not unlike Kiva or Kickstarter, is a clear charity because donors do not get their funds returned. Individual small donors browse project proposals, select one that appeals or that has a good chance of succeeding, and donates directly to that project. Once the donation ask has been met and the project carried out, DonorsChoose posts photos or other evidence of the project’s “success” for donors to view. DonorsChoose projects are limited to public K-12 teachers.

Give Your Time

I find that planning a donation of time or skill much more challenging to manage than giving money. My best experiences have been when I made a weekly time commitment to a single organization/activity for a year at a time. I have also tried a “volunteer vacation,” living and working on-site with an organization for a week, which made for an very satisfying Spring Break.

Those of us without specific summer commitments might even consider a longer volunteer vacation. If you need to stay close to home, maybe you and a campus group can build a Habitat for Humanity house in the parking lot during Winter Term? VolunteerGuide offers a directory of vacation opportunities as exotic as building hiking trails in Iceland and restoring coral reefs in the Caribbean. To google other opportunities, you might also use the search term, “voluntourism.” All or some of your travel and other expenses may be tax deductible for such trips–check with the organization and tax professionals.

Idealist is a clearinghouse for matching volunteers, organizations, and resources. Of all the available services I’ve seen, Idealist’s database offers the most granular advanced search.

Nabuur is a service to link online volunteers to communities in need. It operates something like a Mechanical Turk (see George’s ProfHacker posts on the reliability and ethics of Mechanical Turk) of volunteering; some of the jobs currently listed include designing a form for an orphanage, writing a grant application to support a medical clinic, and soliciting donation of educational materials for a school. As rewarding as it can be to volunteer for non-skilled tasks, many Prof. Hacker readers have spent years honing skills like grant-writing that can be put to exceptionally good use via Nabuur. Additionally, Nabuur may be the opportunity you need to start a service learning project in your classroom.

To volunteer your time in person, VolunteerMatch lists opportunities with 76,000 nonprofits throughout the United States. Originally place-based, VolunteerMatch now includes some virtual opportunities also, though without the intimate or ongoing relationship model of Nabuur. Because VolunteerMatch has national listings and includes one-off and disaster-related options in addition to ongoing volunteer relationships, this service (and its iPhone app) is useful for kickstarting your volunteering while traveling (to conferences, to family, etc.) and relocating or just checking out what’s available in your area.

OneBrick is a calender service connecting short-term volunteers and like-minded people with events and socializing. This could be a good way to meet people and get involved when you relocate!

Give Your Stuff

I keep a box in my coat closet and paper/pencil taped to the inside of the door so I can throw stuff in whenever I decide to clear out household items or clothing appropriate for a thrift store or shelter. When the box is full, it goes in the car to be dropped off and the paper is to keep a running list for tax season. Do take care that items you donate are clean and functional–otherwise your good deed is likely to cause more work and expense for the charity.

Vietnam Veterans does a nice job of collecting important donation information and allows you to schedule a pickup at your house.

Goodwill has stores and donation boxes throughout the US. You can find a drop-off location here.

DonationTown will help you find a local charity to pick up your donations.

Dress for Success collects used business clothing to help disadvantaged women dress appropriately for job interviews. CareerGear dresses men.

Recycles.org will place your used electronics or office gear with needy organizations.

If you’re not in it for the tax deduction, you are very likely to find someone on Freecycle who can put your discards to good use. After joining a local group, you can list available items, then make arrangements with recipients to make a transfer. In my experience, most takers have been happy to pick up something I leave for them on the porch.

Get a Plan

It feels good to give whenever someone asks, buying Girl Scout cookies from a colleague’s kid or giving five bucks to the homeless guy on the corner or filling in at the first aid station for a 5K. If, however, you develop (and follow) a plan for charitable giving (stating goals, deadlines, and evaluation criteria), you’re more likely both to get and feel more accomplished. Here are some ideas:

  • Choose a single organization to support all year. Make a large donation or a regular commitment of time. Host a fundraiser or promote the agency’s programs among friends/family/colleagues.
  • Choose an issue to support for the year. Select a variety of organizations working on that issue (one for each month, one for each paycheck, etc.) and split your annual gift amount among those organizations, given periodically throughout the year. Share information about the issue and each organization with your networks each time you give (via blog, email, phone call, dinner party, tweet…).
  • For each month in the year, select an organization working on an issue of special meaning during that month (e.g. in November, support an organization working on hunger) and promote that cause or organization among the people in your life.
  • Examine your spending during the last month or year (many credit cards now provide a “category summary” of your spending during a month and finance services like Mint tag transactions with spending categories). Choose a charity related to each of your top three spending categories (e.g. if you spent the greatest percentages on books, restaurants, and a dog treats, find charities that support literacy, sustainable farming, and animals) then spread your gift among those three.

Whichever plan you follow, remember to plan also for emergency gifts. This year, many of us will have made a donation related to the March disaster in Japan. Last year, we supported organizations confronting the flooding in Pakistan or the earthquake in Haiti. It’s difficult to plan a gift of time for a disaster situation, but we can plan to set aside an extra monthly monetary gift or two each year (or the equivalent) to have that money available should we wish to donate after a disaster. And, if you are able to donate time or skill during such an event, that is wonderful also.

Get Help

As I have defined it here, philanthropy is charity PLUS encouraging others to support the cause. Think about the networks you already use and whether they can be deployed for philanthropy. Send a tweet every when you give to an organization. Post a link to Facebook. Share a news article on your office door. Bring up your cause at a dinner party. Presumably, the people in your networks have priorities and interests in common with you and (without pushing too hard), these people may be willing to join your cause by giving or by passing along your message. Both are valuable.

In the comments, tell us what causes you support and encourage fellow readers to join you in support. What are your favourite charitable organizations or projects? Why do you support them? How can we help?

Photo by Flickr user Howard Lake / Creative Commons Licensed

 
This entry was posted in Wellness and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

  • Print
  • Comment
  • http://about.me/jbj Jason B. Jones

    My son’s favorite comic book writer, Greg Pak, frequently offers incentives to donate via Twitter. (I.e., “Donate X $$ to charities operating in Haiti, and I’ll send you a signed copy of World War Hulk.”) That’s been an interesting way to bootstrap his interest in giving. (Not just the donation itself! I mean, talking about why Pak might do such a thing, and why it might help spur people to donate.)

  • http://twitter.com/snoballfort Snoball Fort

    Our new company launches soon and we hope to take online donations one step farther. You can see short vid at snoball.co The main idea like these others you showcase is to make it easier and more fun for people to give. We use giving rules to make it a part of everyday, and in small donations so anyone can participate.

  • ruthieo

    Thanks for writing this. I loved this post so much, I bookmarked it! While I was a student, I volunteered much of my time; however, when I started teaching, my devotion shifted from donating time to donating money. My giving is fairly haphazard; my friends are all do-gooders, so I like to donate a modest amount to whatever cause they are promoting on facebook. Hopefully I can reconnect to service through some of the links you posted.

    I can’t say enough about running/swimming/walking/biking for a charity. I’m deeply passionate about Camp Okizu, a Northern California camp for families with childhood cancer, so I fundraised (via FirstGiving!) while I was training for a 10k race. I was completely out of shape, and I don’t think I would have had such commitment to running without the extra motivation. After all, if I didn’t complete the race, I would let all of my donors down! It was truly an amazing experience; I raised awareness and money for my favorite place in the world, while pursuing a healthier life. Talk about a win-win-win situation!

  • shutthemdown

    I just finished working for the for-profit college industry. It was the most terrible experience of my life. I have never seen such racism against staff and students ANYWHERE. These crooks need to be shut down. If you know of a student or staff member attending one of these fake schools, tell them to get the heck out. Students, get attorneys! Protect yourself from these vultures! I even encountered teachers having sex with students. The atmosphere was very hostile. Terrible curriculum. They lie to the students. This is ILLEGAL!

  • shutthemdown

    Come on Democrats! Hold on to these hateful money-hungry crooks, sink your teeth into the legs of this monster and DONT LET GO! BRING THEM DOWN! Anyone who believes in true education is behind you all the way! We must bring fairness back to the minorities of this country. These so called “colleges” are targeting minority students. Grab the nearest video camera and go into these schools and ask the students what they think. Interview the presidents and CEO’s of these places, they will run like chickens.

  • robtcst

    I am a conservative and I vehemently oppose it because it doesn’t apply to public schools as well. Ethnic studies, philosophy and english programs would be would be gone if it applied to publics. The same rules should appy to all types of institutions. By the way, when i graduated from college I had $325 per month student loan payments and was making $1500 per month. Know what I did? I lived low and played little and made the payments every month.

  • 11272784

    I’m sure that the university officials at the fine institutions in Washington and Texas who need income from distance programs are THRILLED that their Governors have found a way to siphon tuition money into WGU instead of attracting more distance students to their state (non)funded institutions.

    Not.

  • sacroiliac

    What, no football team?

  • awegweiser

    Is there no end to the bullsh t that comes from Texas and its Governor(s). The last one worth a damn was Ann Richards.

  • 22118130

    If Governor Rick Perry has anything to do with it, you can be sure it is not good for higher education in Texas. He seems to be the sworn enemy of Texas higher education, and has particularly gone after The University of Texas. He seems to believe if you can be as dumb as he is and make it all the way to governor, and possibly even to president, then who needs an education from a superior institution of learning? Being a native Texan and having spent the last 10-1/2 years with him as governor, I cannot get over how some can possibly back him for president. The man is a joke, even among Texans. 

  • dhberger

    Actually George W. was a pretty good governor, considering he actually worked to get Democrats and Republicans on the same sheet of music. Since Perry has taken over most people of intellect or actually want to help someone have been a target. This from a lifelong Texan and Republican.

  • 3224243

    Mitch Daniels recently approved WGU for Indiana, too.  Out of curiosity, I checked them out and their “recruiting” methods are as high pressure as any for-profit out there.  If I were a governor, I’d be leery of having my name associated with this University of Phoenix wannabe.

  • translog

    Congratulations for the WGU to move into the online education market. I know the benefits of an estab[ished institutions in a competitive market and hope the strategy will floueish witht new courses and programs for Sustainablity and Green Curriculum for  the stakeholders everywhere.This will also be a technology-enabled and supported solution such as Blackberry of RIM..A professor can never better distinguish himself in his work than by encouraging a clever pupil, for the true discoverers are among them, as comets amongst the stars. (innaeus)

    “What we want is to see the child in pursuit of knowledge, and not knowledge in pursuit of the child.” ~George Bernard Shaw

  • major_ray

    Yep. There the cigar smoking back room deal making Republican’s go again. Small change for the little people and they think they are doing God’s work. Less money? Wonder what these ”Re-pubs” plan for hard working under paid professors at the other state colleges? Gonna bust their unions?  Bring back American jobs from overseas and stop the bull!  East coast people are not that stupid. ["Re-pubs" is my answer to their derogatory "democrat party" reference]

  • educationfrontlines

    WGU was established to train teachers online, which makes as much sense as training medical doctors online. Their expansion into other disciplines is even more questionable. The rationale provided by the Indiana governor—that WGU would allow Indiana folks to get a degree when they could not get one from the current state university and tech systems—clearly shows how this will add to the other for-profits’ de-valuing of the U.S. tertiary degree. Already, international observers are anticipating the demise of U.S. quality education due to cheap degrees.  Expensive, but “cheap.”

    John Richard Schrock  

  • dld310

    WGU is NOT a “for-profit institution”. Accredited by NCATE, WGU has been turning out quality teachers for years. The University of Phoenix they are not…and don’t aspire to be. Please don’t lump all online institutions into the same category. Think, and read, before you “speak”.

  • The Chronicle of Higher Education
  • 1255 Twenty-Third St, N.W.
  • Washington, D.C. 20037