• Monday, May 28, 2012

Previous

Next

Academics Upset by Oxford’s Stopping Essay on Indian Epic

November 28, 2011, 10:57 am

Indian and American academics have expressed outrage at a decision by the Indian branch of Oxford University Press to stop publication of an essay about the Hindu mythological epic, the Ramayana, following protests by conservative Hindu groups in India, reports The Hindu, a newspaper in India.

The move comes after the controversial decision by the University of Delhi to remove the essay, “Three Hundred Ramayanas: Five Examples and Three Thoughts on Translation,” by A.K. Ramanujan, from a history course.

The academics, who include such leading Indologists as Sheldon Pollock, of Columbia University, and Wendy Doniger, of the University of Chicago, have written a  public letter to Oxford’s chief executive to express their “shock and dismay” at the decision, which, they argued, was compounded by the Indian branch’s recent apology in court to a Hindu group that had said the essay offended Hindu sensitivities.

The letter calls on the Oxford press to withdraw the apology, publicly state that it is committed to the right of scholars to publish their works without fear of suppression or censorship, and demonstrate this commitment by reprinting Mr. Ramanujan’s collected essays.

A spokesman for the publisher said that it has not yet received the letter but welcomed a dialogue with the scholars, and that scholarly freedom “is of central importance to Oxford University Press.”

 

This entry was posted in India. Bookmark the permalink.

  • Print
  • Comment
  • 22057479

    The essay can be downloaded from several different Internet sites, including here:

    http://www.sacw.net/article2344.html

    and here

    http://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft3j49n8h7&chunk.id=d0e1254

  • Guest

    I bet these professors attacking Oxford are SOBs when they do peer review and get scholars they don’t like blocked all the time. They just don’t see their censorship as censorship.

  • dank48

    Oh, for God’s sake.

  • http://nathaniel-campbell.blogspot.com/ Nathaniel M. Campbell

    Does anyone know what precisely were Mr. Ramanujan’s alleged faults that led to such an uproar?

  • ravirau

    The essay by Ramanujan that can be accessed through the first Comment is excellent, interesting, and worth reading, an example of scholarship by a brilliant scholar. Anyone who reads it will appreciate the richness of the Hindu tradition and its literature in engaging with universal ideas and themes. Presumably, the “conservative Hindu groups” take offense at the irreverence towards and pointing of flaws (especially, what else, sexual!) of the gods, itself however part of the tradition. But most in these groups decrying it are unlikely to have read the essay to appreciate it.   

  • katisumas

    Have you switched from being a  rightwing “Christian”  to being a  rightwing “Hindu” now?

  • http://www.academicroom.com Online Courses

    For the essay see, http://www.academicroom.com/bookchapter/three-hundred-ramayanas-five-examples-and-three-thoughts-translation  – you can click on the Bibliographic Info tab to read responses by Indian intellectuals such as Romila Thapar and a former editor of OUP.

  • http://nathaniel-campbell.blogspot.com/ Nathaniel M. Campbell

    Thanks for the link — after reading the responses, I have a much clearer picture of what happened.