Brainstorm icon

Previous

Should We Assess Learning Outcomes?

Next

Trachtenberg II: The Academic Working Poor

February 24, 2008, 07:33 PM ET

What Should Boys Read?

A correspondent sent me a link to this site, which he and others run. It’s called the iPulp Fiction Library, and it offers for free online fiction in the dime-novel tradition. The titles give an idea of the genre: “There’s Nothing Under the Bed,” “The Great Egress Caper,” and “Wizard’s Boy.” The correspondent says that he thinks these books can bring more teenage boys into the reading habit.

Five years ago I would have written back with something like, “C’mon, can’t we push a little Melville and Swift instead?”

Not anymore. Books of any kind compete with so many digital diversions that just about any fiction that encourages long reading hours is worth a look — pulp or sports or Western or murder mystery or classic novel. Reading researchers believe that sheer volume of reading plays a large role in the acquisition of basic literacy skills and vocabulary, and that print matter of even child-oriented books can be more verbally challenging than some of the best television shows. (Read this entire article and note its far-reaching findings.)

Furthermore, I believe, the boy reading problem is reflected in the growing achievement gap between girls and boys. Admissions officers see this every year. At my old school, UCLA, the entering class last year was 59 percent female. Across town at Cal State-LA, the undergraduate population is 63 percent female. And officials expect the discrepancy to increase.

More leisure reading might help, and books like iPulp Fiction Library’s appeal to boys a lot more than the “problem stories” and identity narratives that fill Young Adult shelves in the libraries and bookstores. Back in high school, I remember boys passing around books as a kind of cool underground connection — including jocks and “stoners” (as they were called then). I was hit hard by The Brothers Karamazov and The Sound and the Fury when I was 18, but those didn’t catch on. What did was Ball Four, a knuckleballer’s diary of a season with the Seattle Pilots; North Dallas Forty, a novel about a receiver for an NFL team; Erica Jong’s Fear of Flying (yes, really); and someone snagged a copy of The Happy Hooker, too.

Do these kinds of secret reading networks still exist? We have Harry Potter, of course, but that’s a different thing, a juggernaut of popularity. Also, there is little evidence that Harry Potter has made many teenage boys read a lot of other books besides Rowling’s. We read the books above not because everybody else did, but because they met a curiosity, or a need, or insecurity, or humor, or heroism that we felt inside, or wanted to. Some of them had some good writing in them, too.

And so, when we spot one teenage boy reading a Conan book, or a Tarzan entry, or some pulp fiction on the train, we should nod and say, “Keep going. Read 50 more this year.”

Image from Photobucket.com

  • Print
  • Comment

Add Your Comment

Commenting is closed.