So you have managed to land a campus visit–congratulations! Now what?
The first thing to ask is how will you get there. If you are lucky, the Search Committee (SC) will make all of the arrangements for you from booking the airfare to arranging for the hotel. But it is becoming more and more common for institutions to require candidates to make their own travel arrangements and submit receipts for reimbursement. This is not a tactic designed to torture job candidates. It’s simply the reality of many college and university business offices. On my most recent campus visit (which was back in 2007), I booked my flight and submitted receipts for airfare and the cab fare to and from the airport in Grad-ville, and the SC arranged for lodging and transportation on their end. On the upside, if you book your own flight, you can select your own flight time and seat, and maybe ever which airport you will depart from (should you live in an area with multiple options). On the downside, this stretches the candidate’s often already thin budget even thinner.
The next thing to ask is what exactly you will be required to do: Job talk? Meeting with students (undergrad and/or grad)? Will you be teaching a class or performing another kind of teaching demonstration? Something else?
What will you need to bring with you?
- Interview clothing: What is appropriate will vary by discipline and location, so I won’t generalize here except to say that in general it’s best to err on the conservative side. Be sure to have footwear appropriate for walking. At some point, you will likely have a campus tour, and you should expect to be on your feet more the better part of the day otherwise, so now is not the time to break in a new pair of heels. Also, be sure to pack your interview clothes in your carry-on bag. You do not want to have to have the SC take you on an emergency Wal-Mart run in the middle of the night because you made it to your destination, but your bag didn’t. This is not an urban myth of the job market variety. It has happened to more than one person I know.
- Materials: In addition to my job talk and the text/notes/handouts for the class I was scheduled to teach, I also brought a copy of my CV, my dissertation abstract, and a few sample syllabi. Lastly, I had my laptop which had all the rest of my job materials, including my entire dissertation, just in case. If you aren’t planning to travel with a laptop, I would recommend carrying a flashdrive with any relevant job materials just in case. It is much better to have them and not need them than to need them and not have them.
- A few snacks and maybe some mints. Interview days can be long days, and particularly if you are changing time zones, it’s a good idea to have an energy bar or two in your bag just in case you start to get hungry or feel your energy lag a bit. Also, for many people, stress and nerves can cause dry mouth or yucky tasting mouth. You don’t need either hunger or halitosis to distract you from the task at hand, which is of course, being the most excellent version of yourself that you can muster.
- Assorted gadgets (cellphone, mp3 player, etc.) & their chargers. Maybe you have trouble sleeping in a strange place, or maybe listening to your favorite band will help you to take the edge off the night before your big day. That’s fine. MP3 players are also useful for communicating “Leave Me Alone” to the chatty person you find yourself next to on the plane. Just don’t forget to turn off any ringers. Having the candidate’s phone go off in the middle of a job talk does not impress.
When you get there:
- Your interview begins the moment you step off that plane, and it doesn’t end until you get back on the plane to go home. There is no “down time” unless you are in the hotel alone, and even then, you should be using that time to either sleep or prepare for the next activity on your agenda.
- You might be given a tour of neighborhoods near campus. Some SCs arrange for candidates to meet with a real estate agent so they can see the kinds of living arrangements that faculty might afford.
- You will likely have breakfast, lunch, and dinner with members of the SC as well as with other members of the campus community. Depending on the size of the department, other faculty who are not on the SC might join you. Students might be invited to join you. Or it might just be the SC. Don’t worry about what to order–choose something that you like, unless you are like me and have a tendency to wear your food. In that case, choose something that will blend in with your shirt. Different people will have different advice about whether or not you should order a drink with dinner. If you are not comfortable with alcohol, now is not the time to experiment. If the SC order a glass of wine or a beer, and you want one, go ahead, but generally, it’s a good idea to stick to a single drink. Or you might play it safe and stick with water/diet soda/iced tea/non-alcoholic beverage of choice.
- Be excited about your research. The SC thinks that you have something to offer the department, so don’t undersell yourself by being modest. I’m not saying that you should be a pompous ass, but it’s good to be enthusiastic about your work, about opportunities that the department might provide, about classes that you might teach.
- It’s also a good idea to show that you are interested in the position and are excited about the job.
- You can expect to meet with a wide range of people during your visit: faculty, students, administrators, and maybe even a College President. If you are given a list of these people, do your homework. I’m not suggesting that you stalk them, but it doesn’t hurt to see what kind of classes they are teaching, what kinds of projects they’ve recently worked on, or what their background might be.
- Be friendly and collegial, and above all, be yourself. If you have made it to the campus visit, chances are the SC think that you have what it takes to do the job. Now they are trying to see which of the three candidates might be the best fit for the campus community. Do they want to work with you day in and day out for the next 3, 5, 15+ years?
- Do your best to go with the flow. No matter how prepared you are, something will happen that you did not anticipate. Maybe the computer refuses to read your PowerPoint presentation. Maybe the flight arrives 3 hours late. Maybe a member of the SC gets food poisoning while you are out to dinner. Stuff happens. Deal the best that you can and try not to get too rattled, no matter what (and believe me when I tell you that I speak from experience on this one).
- I’ll also add a link to Cheryl Ball’s “Get a Job!” website, which features some helpful advice and information, including the answer to the question: “what do we talk about in the car on the way from the airport?” Her site has info for all stages of the job market geared towards those seeking a position in English.
Afterwards:
- Thank you notes are appropriate, especially if someone went out of their way to help you during your visit. These can be emailed or written and sent the old-fashioned post-office way. But a thank-you note is not going to resurrect a flailing candidate, nor is the lack of a note going to tank an otherwise successful one.
- Try not to psyche yourself out about what order you were. It really doesn’t matter, and you can’t change it now even if it did, but this is one factor people like to obsess over.
- Try to be patient. The one way that order does matter is in the way it affects the timeline for interviews and an offer. It always takes longer than you think for a search to run its course. Not only do all three candidates need to visit, but then the SC needs to meet and pick someone. Sometimes, there is an obvious frontrunner, but often there isn’t. Sometimes it is easy to reach a consensus quickly, but often it isn’t. Sometimes, the SC reports their recommendation directly to the dean, but sometimes they have to report to the entire department who then must vote. No news is no news.
- It might be the case that the offer goes to another candidate first, and they decline for whatever reason. Maybe they got a better offer elsewhere. Maybe their spouse has flat-out refused to move to [X]. Maybe they were trying to leverage this offer against their current institution. In any event, it isn’t over until it’s over.
- Try to remember that even if you don’t get the offer, it doesn’t mean that you necessarily did something wrong. It is entirely possible that you did everything right, and yet the offer stil went to someone else because they too did everything right and managed to bring a little extra to the table. All you can do is the best you can do.
Do you have advice to add from either the candidate’s perspective or the perspective of a SC member? Please share suggestions, stories, and experiences in the comments section. And to all of you on the market, we wish you the very best of luck!
[Creative Commons licensed photo by I Don't Know, Maybe.]



Comments
1. Jonathan Dresner - March 02, 2010 at 06:32 pm
All good stuff. I did have luggage lost on my way to a national conference interview -- it arrived later, but I'd scouted out the Men's Wearhouse around the corner in case it didn't -- so I definitely second the carry-on idea.
I wouldn't assume, by the way, that the interview begins when you arrive. There's always the possibility -- I know it sounds a bit paranoid, but I've traveled to some smaller airports -- that someone from the University is on the plane, either going or coming.
The last thing I'll suggest is that you should never assume the political or intellectual stances of the faculty you meet. Don't hide your views, where they're relevant, but don't assume that everyone will agree with you.
2. Erin E. Templeton - March 02, 2010 at 06:38 pm
Thanks Jonathan--good points!
3. cheryl ball - March 02, 2010 at 07:52 pm
Hey, thanks for linking to the job site I maintain with my colleague, Katherine Ellison. We had a lot of fun putting it together based on our various profdevs during grad school as well as from experience in two searches (for both of us). If folks have suggestions, let me know and I'll add to the site!
4. JoVE - March 02, 2010 at 09:25 pm
Also good to remember that in an interview is a 2-way process. The SC is trying to see if you will fit with the campus committee BUT SO ARE YOU.
As strange as it may be to say, people do turn down jobs, and not just because of spouses. If you are lucky enough to be offered more than one job, what is it about this place that would make you choose it (or not)? And is this someplace you can really see yourself working and living? Could you work with these people?
You can't always tell a lot from a campus visit but it is worth at least considering these things and maybe taking some notes before you go to bed at night in case you need them later.
5. Erin Sells - March 02, 2010 at 09:31 pm
Thanks, Erin! This has really helped me wrap my brain around what's coming next week--in a very practical way. My advisor has been counseling me on the three E's--Energy, Excitement, Enthusiasm. If you're like me and you tend you hold your cards close to your chest, sometimes you need to reminded to SHOW some of that genuine excitement about the possibilities.
6. winterbourne - March 03, 2010 at 12:02 pm
The most important advice in this article is that there is, indeed, no down time during a job interview. Not even - and in fact, especially not - during activities that may seem earmarked as down time. That 7 pm meeting with junior faculty during happy hour at a local bar - definitely not down time, no matter how much smack about the institution everybody else is talking. And that tour of town with a friendly local realtor? Also not down time. The latter point may seem paranoid, but I'm totally serious. If you think about it, the kinds of questions that realtors ask - "so, do you see yourself having kids soon?" "is proximity to a church or synagogue important to you?" - are precisely the kinds of questions that a search committee would like to ask, but can't, for legal reasons. When I first went out on the market, I was warned that some search committees might use realtors to scout out their applicants. I thought this was totally preposterous, until I met my first real estate agent on a flyout and discovered - at the end of a very long and involved tour - that she was the spouse of the search committee chair...
7. Richard Parent - March 03, 2010 at 12:48 pm
I'd just add that it's really very important to do your research on the campus and department BEFORE you get there. You should arrive with a series of questions that show that you not only know the department, but that you've seriously thought about how you would (and would not) fit in there as a colleague and a productive member of the community.
8. Erin Templeton - March 03, 2010 at 02:13 pm
I think a good general rule of thumb is that if there is something that you don't want to get back to the S, it shouldn't come out of your mouth until you are back home talking to the dog.
9. Erin Sells - March 03, 2010 at 02:18 pm
So here's a follow-up question, then--suppose someone does ask you one of those illegal/inappropriate questions ("do you want kids?" "are you married?" etc.). What would be a more graceful response than "That's illegal and none of your business, bozo"?
10. Erin Templeton - March 03, 2010 at 02:50 pm
I don't think that there's a one-size-fits-all answer to these kinds of things. I haven't been asked "illegal" questions (technically, I don't think asking is illegal, but it's discriminating based on answers that is the problem). I wasn't asked any of these problematic questions personally, but there were times during the visit when the conversation veered into talking about children (I don' have any). No one asked me about kids, but if i wanted to, there would have been the space to jump in and offer the info. I think that I said something about my friend's child. I then probably just asked them questions about their kids, and it was fine.
And in general, I don't think that most SCs are machevellian by nature. Even in the case of the real estate agent, it might well have been intended to give candidates a sense of the area. I could see having a spouse do the tour because asking someone unrelated to the dept would be kind of an imposition (I mean, 2/3 candidates will not be moving, and the third might not be buying).
In general, it is best to assume good intentions rather than ulterior motives (unless you have irrefutable proof to the contrary). If the SC has brought you to campus, they like you. They want to see you do well on the interview, etc. They're not trying to trip you up or humiliate you or trick you.
11. Robert Wolff - March 03, 2010 at 03:37 pm
Job candidates should also Google themselves, because the SC certainly will. Do a general Google search, then used an advanced search restricted to your graduate institution's web (e.g., umn.edu), and possibly undergrad institution as well. Be prepared for search committee members to know things about you that you didn't put in your c.v., such as the amount and recipient of any political campaign donations you have made recently, your time in that 10K last fall, and the sarcastic comments you made about someone's research on a listserv. It should go without saying that if you use social networking sites, consider what info you want public.
12. Dr. Virago - March 05, 2010 at 03:47 pm
I'm a little late commenting on this, but for posterity's sake I wanted to share a light story about what could go wrong (and how it's not the end of the world).
At one of my campus visits two potential disasters happened. First, in the middle of my guest teaching (which some places ask you to do in addition to a traditional job talk), the overhead projector pens started to leak all over my hands, but I didn't notice until about the third or fourth color did it. When I did notice, I might have paused for a second, but I kept calm, smiled, and said something like, "Huh. Look at that. Oh well, it wasn't bothering me before, so I'm not going to let it bother me now." (I really wanted to say, "Well, better than chalk on my butt," but thought better of it.)
Then, on the same visit, the faculty member who was driving me to dinner made an illegal u-turn over a median that she couldn't see in the dark, completely flattening two of her tires in the process. She was absolutely mortified, but I remained cheerful and reassured her that I also hadn't seen the median (it really was poorly lit) and certainly didn't say anything about the mid-road U-turn. In the end, we had a rather relaxed and cheerful dinner because that experience completely chased away any social stiffness that might have been there to begin with. Nothing like shared trauma (it was a little frightening as we went over the median) to bring people together!
Anyway, neither incident affected either my view of the school and its faculty (though the town needed better lighting!) or their view of me. I ended up pulling out of consideration for that job because I got an offer from somewhere else that I wanted to be more, and when I did that, the SC tried really hard to convince me to stay in consideration, so clearly my visit went well.
The moral of the story? Keep your cool and your sense of humor.
13. JoVE - March 06, 2010 at 09:50 am
Sometimes those questions are just a poorly worded way to ask something else. Like how seriously you are considering this particular job or how committed you are to your research. So you can also fish a little bit for that deeper concern and then respond directly to that.
I had a friend who was asked (during one of the more informal parts of the visit) things like "Is your husband happy to move here?" and even whether she planned on having more kids. And I think to the former you can just say something like "My husband is very supportive of my career. I wouldn't be here if I wasn't seriously considering a move." You could even leave out that first sentence.
But sometimes people are just trying to be friendly. They might ask about your husband because they want to know how they could make it easier for him, or they would highlight things that might be attractive to him about the town. Same with kids. If their school district has a great reputation, they might think that's a good selling point for you (and it might well be).
Add Your Comment
Commenting is closed.