Previous |
Next |
November 16, 2009, 02:00 PM ET
5 Things Professors Don't Know: First of a Series
I asked the brave and astute students in my upper-division nonfiction creative-writing class what they'd say if offered the chance to address the faculty. They responded with alacrity, sending in their work before the deadline and writing with a sense of authority derived from many years of classroom observation.
This is the first in the series. Written by Alana Wenick, it offers an excellent introduction to what is now known as "The 5 Things Assignment":
Professors: Some we love, some we hate, and all of them we need. But you can't tell a professor how you feel because they hold the keys to your future in their bony hands. I could, of course, try to offer up some constructive criticism, but I have a feeling that the conversation would go a lot like this: "Oh, so you don't think I put enough information on the slides, Alana? Can you say that a little louder? I can't hear you over this massive ‘F' that I'm writing on your paper."
With that in mind, I'll share a few things that I wish professors knew (but I was always too afraid to say to them):
1) I have never MLA-cited anything by myself in my entire life. Ever. Writing your own citations ended around the same time that people discovered the incredibleness that is easybib.com. Professors may want us to do it the old-fashioned way (you know, the way that actually requires the firing of neurons) but then again I wanted an A in Physics and a pony for my birthday. Looks like we can't all get what we want. I mean, let's be real, if I can have my citation done for me with three mouse clicks, why try to do it myself? Now that the technology is available, we shouldn't deny ourselves its usefulness. That's like telling math majors that they have to do all of their addition and subtraction without an abacus.
2) I'm sorry to any future Ph.D. candidates who are reading this right now, but if you look like a celebrity, political figure, or tabloid personality, don't even bother getting that degree. We will not listen to you. Ever. The entire time we will merely be distracted by the fact that we're being taught by a look-a-like. Rather than focusing on the reading, entire class periods will be devoted to trying to get a picture of you on our cellphones. You'll have better luck getting us to pay attention if you grow a unibrow and teach in a clown costume. I had a Sporty Spice look-alike once and every time she opened her mouth I envisioned her wearing a sports bra and dancing around to "Spice Up Your Life." Even better, my roommate once had "President Palmer" from "24" teach her Microbiology. After President Palmer died in the show, we would sit around all day imagining conspiracy theories regarding him hiding out in Storrs, Conn. UConn was like his bat cave. We could only hope to be his Catwomen. Needless to say, few female students did well in that class.
3) You probably know this just as well as we do, but seeing you in a place outside of the academic setting is one of the most awkward moments ever. When you're done with class everyday we like to think that you disappear, surfacing at random moments to check your email, and then slinking back into oblivion. We imagine all professors kind of like holograms, turning on for class and then pressing the off-button afterwards. Bathrooms are especially awkward. If I hear you peeing next to me I am instantly uncomfortable and slightly nauseated. Not to mention the added stall-to-stall conversation is completely disturbing. Okay, Dr. Chatty Cathy?
4) If you literally read off of a paper for an hour and fifteen minutes this does not count as a lecture. Everyone will either be asleep or hate you. I had a professor once do this for the full 14 weeks of the semester. She would often pause and look up at us, as if expecting some sort of a reaction. What did she expect us to do? Stand up and break out in raucous applause? If you can't remember the material, than why should we?
5) There is no need to put those "just for fun" optional readings on the syllabus. We will never read them. If I even see the word "optional" my eyes glaze over and I will go back to thinking of something pointless, like how many grapes I can possibly stick in my mouth without suffocating. There's a better chance of me shimmying into class followed by a conga line of maroon pandas than actually reading your optional paper. If you really wanted us to read it in the first place it would have been mandatory.
All right, so now that that's out in the open I'm just going to hide in my room for the next couple of days. You never know which professor might catch wind of this. Or I may read one of those "just for fun" articles. Meh, who am I kidding? My roommate has "24" on and I think I'm hearing President Palmer. And he's definitely not talking about microbiology.


Comments
1. literarytype - November 16, 2009 at 03:10 pm
Why didn't I think of this? I'm going to use the prompt for my next class and suggest that others in my department do likewise. Thanks for the inspiration and thanks to your student for her willingness to share her witty but also wise ideas.
2. lilyb - November 16, 2009 at 03:41 pm
Sorry, but number 2 above is slightly humorous but also pretty insulting to most undergraduates. They're not all that easily distracted. Also, I've had plenty of students that look like someone famous. Am I not going to take them seriously because of some coincidental resemblance? Surely Ms. Wenick could come up with something less juvenile.
3. literarytype - November 16, 2009 at 04:01 pm
lilyb, you have plenty of famous looking students? Where do you teach? And are there any openings?
4. katiebeautifulkatie - November 16, 2009 at 06:39 pm
Hey, Alana, nice work! Congratulations on being in the Chronicle.
GB, I look forward to more of these.
5. jffoster - November 17, 2009 at 06:45 am
Immature.
6. leontrout - November 17, 2009 at 08:47 am
Oh, please use an auto-bib program in one of my classes. And also please, PLEASE use this cutely smug tone when you write papers for me.
7. bumblebuzz88 - November 17, 2009 at 11:37 am
my advice to professors is to stop being so snotty to a student who is willing to put her work up on an academic website. we all know you're better than us, blahblahblah, so stop trying to show off and maybe you'll learn something as well as enjoy yourself. it is possible, yanno.
love ya.
ps to leontrout: vonnegut would hate you.
8. bumblebuzz88 - November 17, 2009 at 11:40 am
pps: also, jffoster, people stop using the word "immature" when they're, like, twelve. if you're too old for twilight, it's time for you to stop throwing the "i" word around.
9. jffoster - November 18, 2009 at 07:00 am
Ok "bumblebuzz", or is that 'bubblewrapbrain', would you prefer 'juvenile'? And mature people use the word 'immature' when it fits.
10. sciencelibrarian - November 18, 2009 at 11:11 am
I'm surprised at Alana's first point. Do her instructors really want her to construct citations by hand, rather than use a tool that makes them automatically from the bibliographic information? That's just a matter of mechanically following rules. At my university we have a site license for RefWorks, and we strongly encourage students to use it when making their reference lists.
11. janacat - November 19, 2009 at 07:40 am
There is no excuse for poor lectures except on an off day. Teaching well is part of the professor's job. But there also is no excuse for the common belief among students that a professor's job is to compel them to learn. If you don't want to be in college, do the work, and take the responsibility you demand as "adults," leave that seat open for someone else.
12. unhdennis - November 19, 2009 at 04:35 pm
When I was a 17 year old freshman 40+ years ago (or when the academis dinosaurs roamed the earth), I had an economic history professor who read his lectures. He spoke in a monotone, never raised his eyes to the class to acknowledge that we were even there and bolted out the door at the end of class.
I sat there not knowing how to ask a question without interupting him from his reading to us. Finally, when I summoned up the courage to interupt him and tried, he fixed me with a withering gaze and ignored my attempt to question him.
I earned a good grade, but never tried to ask a question again. I have never forgotten this class as I have many others. Why would someone go into teaching with no interest in actually teaching students.
13. leontrout - November 20, 2009 at 12:31 pm
Mr. Vonnegut liked me quite well, thank you, you immature person.
14. michygeary - November 20, 2009 at 05:31 pm
Alana,
Fantastic essay. You write bravely and truthfully. I loved the description of celebrities teaching your classes. It's not something I've ever really encountered (wait, except that time John Mayer taught me Algebra II... that was VERY distracting) so President Palmer teaching Microbiology was delightful to read.
Don't sweat anyone who's giving you grief over your very valid and honest points. The only ones who are harping so hard are professors who are guilty of those things themselves. Otherwise they wouldn't take it so personally.
15. fridaygirl - November 22, 2009 at 08:21 am
Very funny, Alana. It's true on lazy days I'm tempted just to read lectures out loud, but knowing there are students like Alana out there, I resist the urge. Also, now I can be grateful that I look nothing like Angelian Jolie! JN
16. demery1 - November 23, 2009 at 10:01 am
Such a fine start to a rapidly deteriorating sequence of articles....
Every morning I curse my Brad Pitt countenance for just this reason.
17. katiebeautifulkatie - November 23, 2009 at 06:28 pm
#16--You're right that this is a great start but all of them have been funny and insightful if readers could give themselves a chance to laugh. Even though this was a calm and measured essay, less aggressive than the later ones, commenters did jump in with "immature" right away, which indicates that the readers, not the writers, were looking for a fight.
18. drgrieves - November 24, 2009 at 07:27 pm
Alana: Do you want to be dragged into this? Seeing that you have gone pretty well unnoticed, do you prefer the anonymity? Or do you feel that you are missing out on the wonderful experience that (according to Professor B) you classmates are having?
Katieetc: I think that a LOT of people are laughing.
Add Your Comment
Commenting is closed.