Posts by Tom Bartlett
May 15, 2013, 01:30 PM ET
'The Strangest Conference I Ever Attended'
David Birnbaum believes he has
unified the fields of religion and science. He told me so in an
e-mail. A book he wrote, Summa Metaphysica, Volumes I and
II, "unifies the two fields—elegantly—and seemlessly" (sic). In
April of last year, Bard College devoted a three-day* conference to the role of metaphysics in science
and religion, prompted by the "reflections flowing" from Birnbaum's
books, according to a program e-mailed to participants from
prestigious institutions including Dartmouth, Grinnell, and Oxford.
"We are especially pleased to announce that David Birnbaum will be
present during discussion," the program enthused. Left unmentioned
was that Birnbaum helped finance the conference, that he has no
academic affiliation, and that his works are published by an entity
that he himself runs, called "Harvard Matrix" or "Harvard Yard
Press" or, as sometimes printed on the spines of...
Read More
November 5, 2012, 06:38 PM ET
The Rise of the Poll Quants (or, Why Sam Wang Might Eat a Bug)
September 5, 2012, 03:55 PM ET
Former Harvard Psychologist Fabricated and Falsified, Report Says
- Hauser published "fabricated data" in a paper on how cotton-top tamarin monkeys learn rules. In one of the graphs "half of the data" was made up. That paper has since been retracted.
- Hauser falsified coding in two other experiments with tamarins "making the results statistically significant when the results coded by others showed them to be nonsignificant." Those experiments...
August 30, 2012, 06:06 PM ET
Sociologist Defends Controversial Gay-Parenting Study in New Paper
In the introduction to a new paper answering his critics, Mark Regnerus writes that his gay-parenting study "raised a variety of questions" among readers. That is a bit of an understatement. The paper started a controversy that has yet to die down, with critics questioning the motives of Regnerus, an associate professor of sociology at the University of Texas at Austin, as well as his research methods. The new paper, which is a commentary and not a peer-reviewed study, was published online on Monday, a couple of days before the University of Texas released the results of an inquiry into the original study that found no evidence of scientific misconduct. (The university's report did not rule out the possibility that the study might be "seriously flawed," finding only that there was no apparent ethical breach.) It's worth noting, again, that the audit of Regnerus's original paper by...
Read MoreAugust 29, 2012, 07:59 PM ET
U. of Texas Finds No Scientific Misconduct by Author of Gay-Parenting Study
An inquiry by the University of Texas at Austin has found no evidence of scientific misconduct by Mark Regnerus, an associate professor of sociology whose controversial gay-parenting study caused a stir when it was published, in June. But, according to a report released on Wednesday by the university, that does not mean the study isn't "seriously flawed," only that there was no evidence of falsification or other unethical practices. The inquiry was prompted by a complaint by Scott Rose, a blogger for the New Civil Rights Movement who has aggressively covered the Regnerus case. As part of the inquiry, Regnerus's computers, e-mail, and grant applications were examined, and the professor responded to each of Rose's allegations. According to the university's report, the inquiry found that "[n]one of the allegations of scientific misconduct put forth by Mr. Rose were substantiated either...
Read MoreAugust 21, 2012, 01:24 PM ET
The Monk and the Gunshot
When human beings are startled, we raise our shoulders and close our eyes. Our blood vessels constrict, and our pulse quickens. The startle response is a well-documented phenomenon; one of the first studies to examine it was published in 1939, and there's even an entire book on the subject. An involuntary reaction to, say, a very loud noise is thought to be deeply primitive and impossible to overcome. Try to stifle it, and you will almost certainly fail. Unless, perhaps, you're a Buddhist monk with 40 years of experience in meditation like Matthieu Ricard. Born in France, a son of the philosopher Jean-François Revel, Ricard has a doctorate in cell genetics and serves as the French interpreter for the Dalai Lama. Researchers decided to see if Ricard, with decades of meditation under his belt, would respond differently to being startled than those of us with decades of being...
Read MoreAugust 15, 2012, 02:01 PM ET
Harvard Sociologist Says His Research Was ‘Twisted’
July 26, 2012, 10:57 PM ET
Controversial Gay-Parenting Study Is Severely Flawed, Journal's Audit Finds
The peer-review process failed to identify significant, disqualifying problems with a controversial and widely publicized study that seemed to raise doubts about the parenting abilities of gay couples, according to an internal audit scheduled to appear in the November issue of the journal, Social Science Research, that published the study. The highly critical audit, a draft of which was provided to The Chronicle by the journal's editor, also cites conflicts of interest among the reviewers, and states that "scholars who should have known better failed to recuse themselves from the review process." Since it was published last month, the study, titled "How Different Are the Adult Children of Parents Who Have Same-Sex Relationships?," has been the subject of numerous news articles and blog posts. It has been used by opponents of same-sex marriage to make their case, and it's been blasted...
Read MoreJuly 18, 2012, 11:50 AM ET
An Economist Finds Herself in the Political Cross Hairs
On Monday, President Obama made fun of Mitt Romney's jobs plan, citing a commentary by an economist who estimated that his proposal to shift to a so-called territorial corporate-tax system—that is, to exempt American corporations from taxes on their foreign income—would cause them to move their operations overseas, creating 800,000 jobs in other countries. The commentary was by Kimberly A. Clausing, a professor of economics at Reed College, and published in Tax Notes. She doesn't mention Mitt Romney by name, writing that "others" are pushing for such a system, but it's clear who she's talking about, and it's obvious that she thinks it's a bad idea. "U.S. tax payments for the income from foreign operations of U.S. multinational corporations would not simply be deferred; they would be completely erased," she writes. "That would eliminate constraints on shifting income abroad." Clausing ...
Read MoreJuly 17, 2012, 01:01 PM ET
The Broken Escalator; Or, Can You Ever Really Retract a Paper?
It's a clear, curious,
irresistible finding. In a
study published in March of last year in the Journal of
Experimental Social Psychology, researchers tracked donations
to the Salvation Army from mall shoppers who had just taken the up
escalator versus those who had just stepped off the down. They
found that more than twice as many of the recently elevated gave
money (16 percent compared with 7 percent). Articles about the
study appeared in
Scientific American,
New Scientist, and multiple other outlets, each with the
obligatory escalator stock photo like the one above. Even though
the finding is pretty recent, it's showed up in several books,
including Get Lucky: How to Put Planned Serendipity to Work for
You and Your Business and Brainfluence: 100 Ways to
Persuade and Convince Consumers With Neuromarketing. The lead
author of the study is Lawrence Sanna, who
resigned in May from the...
Read More

