Posts by David Evans
January 22, 2010, 02:47 PM ET
Who Pays for Campus Interviews?
A recent thread in The Chronicle's Forums discusses whether or not an institution conducting on-campus visits should pay for candidates' expenses for interviewing.
I know it's an uncommon practice for community colleges; until recently, such institutions hired almost entirely locally. (That is changing, though, with the oversupply of Ph.D.'s in many disciplines and the increasing aspirations of community colleges.) I am explicitly not talking about such colleges here.
That leaves four-year colleges and universities, from the fanciest liberal-arts colleges and research universities, public and private, to the dustiest, remotest, smallest regional institutions. For any of them, there is no reasonable justification for declining to pay expenses for campus interviews.
If a college cannot afford such interviews, it cannot afford to hire tenure-track faculty members. An expensive campus...
Read MoreJanuary 13, 2010, 01:00 PM ET
Decisions, Decisions
It's again the season when my university makes job offers, and so I’ve been thinking about how long to allow candidates to respond to them once they are on the table.
This year has been a little unusual compared with last year. I've made offers for two positions: One had a very small pool, while the other had a significantly larger pool than anyone here had anticipated. Those different scenarios have very different implications for handling offers.
While I understand from an institutional standpoint why a hiring college or university wants a quick answer to offers, I also wonder about places that pressure candidates significantly on their time frames. The Modern Language Association, for instance, recommends giving candidates a two-week window, which seems pretty reasonable to me. I strongly believe that institutions that pressure candidates to accept immediately or very quickly, or...
Read MoreJanuary 8, 2010, 01:00 PM ET
Bad Weather: Practical Advice
My previous entry discussed some issues about managing on-campus interviews in bad weather. One of the commenters asked what kinds of candidate behavior have impressed my institutions when bad weather strikes. While I do have some specific anecdotes, a little further thought—yesterday when I was stuck at my house in blizzard conditions and again this morning while I was waiting for the plow to remove the 8' drifts from the road in front of our house—has led me to think more in terms of specific, practical advice for candidates and institutions.
For candidates:
• Make sure that you ask whomever is
coordinating the interview for several contact numbers, including
ones you can use outside of office hours. Ideally, get the number
for the person who's scheduled to pick you up at the airport.
• If you don't already have one, get a cell phone
with a national calling plan, even if you...
January 5, 2010, 09:00 AM ET
Campus Interviews in Bad Weather
Anyone following the national news during the last two weeks has
heard about the disastrous weather system that overtook much of the
country over the holidays. In our corner of Iowa, we received over
two feet of snow, and driving through town is currently quite
hazardous as the piles of snow on the curbs are, in places,
head-high.
It's also the season of on-campus interviews. Candidates are flying
to colleges and universities all over the country on trips that
often involve layovers, passing through airports in cities
(e.g., Chicago, Minneapolis-St. Paul) that often have
disastrous weather at this time of year. Roads are icy or covered
with snow. Candidates from warm climates are flying to places like
Iowa, where the temperature on my computer currently reads 0
degrees Fahrenheit.
Earlier in my career, at another institution in Iowa, I often
oversaw candidate visits to campus after the...
January 4, 2010, 11:00 AM ET
More on the Challenges of International Programs
In my last
post, I discussed the challenges of managing international
programs and the concomitant implications for faculty hiring and
the shape of faculty careers. Meanwhile (and this is why I've been
gone for a while), I've just returned from an 11-day trip to
Singapore and Seoul, the planning for which inspired me to write
about such programs.
One of the commenters on that last entry provided some very
interesting and thoughtful discussion about the high costs and
excessive travel involved in conducting such programs, and raised
the possible alternative of teleconferencing and other virtual
modes of delivery. Believe me, I have been thinking a lot about
those options as my institution considers a possible foray into
Singapore.
There are, however, some cost and other issues that could make
moving wholly or largely to a virtual presence in international
locations challenging. For starters...
December 9, 2009, 11:00 AM ET
The Challenges of International Programs
There is a tremendous amount of discussion in administrative
circles, and in higher education more generally, about the rise of
the so-called "global university" and the need for institutions to
develop a significant presence in the world beyond the United
States. This discussion often centers on countries like China and
India, where a growing, education-hungry population and rapidly
developing economies promise great opportunities for American
institutions that manage to create and maintain a strong presence
in those places.
At my previous institution, we had a large program in Singapore,
which is, conveniently enough, a kind of cultural crossroads
between China and India. We had several hundred students from the
region enrolled, and the program was highly successful academically
and financially for the university.
The challenge of such a program lies in its management. We had
a...
December 3, 2009, 10:00 AM ET
'People Like Us'
I received a couple of private responses to my last
entry on the efforts of Iowa's private colleges and
universities to strengthen recruitment of diverse faculty members.
I'm grateful for those responses and appreciate the ideas and
suggestions from my correspondents.
One mentioned the tendency of search committees to eliminate or
give lesser consideration to diverse candidates because the
committee members are more comfortable with colleagues who are like
themselves. This is a concern often expressed when recruiting
diverse faculty members is discussed. For one thing, it calls into
question another truism of faculty recruitment, which is that there
aren't that many strong multicultural candidates to be had,
particularly in fields that are not grossly overproducing
Ph.D.'s.
There is a lot of truth in the point that search committees often
tend to gravitate towards candidates who resemble...
November 25, 2009, 12:00 PM ET
Diversity in Iowa
The other day, I was at a meeting of the chief academic officers
from institutions affiliated with the Iowa Association of
Independent Colleges and Universities. IAICU serves as the
consolidated voice of Iowa's private institutions (almost all of
which are active members) in state and national governmental
affairs, and as a clearinghouse for information-sharing and other
activities that serve the common interests of those
institutions.
For the last two years, we've been discussing how to increase the
diversity of our faculty at IAICU institutions. For many reasons,
this is a very tall challenge. Most importantly, Iowa has a
reputation for being not very diverse, and therefore perhaps not
very welcoming to people who do not have a European-American
heritage and ethnicity. In addition, most of the private
institutions in Iowa are, like mine, relatively small and
teaching-oriented, with all ...
November 16, 2009, 09:00 AM ET
Hiring for the Mission
My last
entry on small private colleges' need to find faculty members
who can cover a wide range of courses was inspired by comments I
heard at various sessions of the Council of Independent Colleges'
annual institute for chief academic officers. Another interesting,
and somewhat related conversation occurred at the dinner meeting of
the CAOs at Presbyterian colleges, which was sponsored by the
Association of
Presbyterian Colleges & Universities. The discussion, led
by Robert Holyer, Provost at Presbyterian College in Clinton, SC,
concerned recruiting and socializing new faculty members to meet
the mission of member colleges in APCU.
APCU institutions have a wide range of missions and characters. A
couple of the CAOs participating in the dinner came from
institutions that continue to require faith statements from their
faculty members, though these statements are quite different
from...
November 11, 2009, 04:00 PM ET
In Search of the Flexible Candidate
I've spent the past several days at the Council of Independent
Colleges' annual Institute for Chief Academic Officers. The CIC is
an association of small and midsize private institutions that
offers its members developmental conferences such as this one, a
similar one for presidents, a series of workshops for chairs, and
other programs and projects including a valuable tuition-exchange
program for children of faculty and staff members.
While a number of the more elite private institutions are members,
for the most part the academic officers attending this institute
were from the less rarified strata of private higher education. As
such, many of the discussions revolved around the issues that have
been the subject of my entries here for some time: attracting and
retaining a strong faculty out of the limelight of prestige and
outside compelling locations; how graduate programs can
prepare...

