• April 21, 2014

New E-Textbooks Do More Than Inform: They'll Even Grade You

The earliest electronic textbooks simply offered the text of the printed book on a computer. Today's newest models, though, come with an array of features, including software tools that automatically grade homework for professors or let students share their margin notes with friends online.

A new line of e-textbooks scheduled to be unveiled on Tuesday by McGraw-Hill Higher Education, for instance, comes bundled with "lecture capture" software, so professors can use the built-in microphone and camera on a laptop computer to record their lectures for students, as well as with other features that are new for textbook publishers.

At the core of the new products are still the electronic versions of the traditional textbooks, but they are designed to let students quickly jump between specific chapters, say, and the portion of a professor's recorded lecture that covers that subject matter.

The company calls its new set of electronic textbooks "McGraw-Hill Connect," and the program includes about 100 titles in 18 disciplines, company officials said in interviews last week.

In some ways, the latest e-textbooks from McGraw-Hill and others compete with course-management software offered by Blackboard and other companies, though publishers say they are working in partnership with those companies rather than as rivals.

Adoption of electronic textbooks has been slow, and McGraw-Hill Connect is just the latest attempt by a major textbook publisher to nudge the format forward. Publishers could benefit if students take to electronic versions because most online books cannot be resold by students. The reuse of print textbooks cuts into sales of new titles, and brings no revenue to publishers.

Edward H. Stanford, president of McGraw-Hill Higher Education, said in an interview that the new e-textbooks were developed based on an ethnographic investigation of student study habits done by the company. He said the company learned that students often do not study in a linear fashion, but instead jump around in the text, whether in print or electronic textbooks. "One kid in a biology class said, 'I don't read the chapter. I just look at the art. If I understand the art, I go on to the next art. If I don't understand the art, I read,'" said Mr. Stanford. "When he said that, it made perfect sense to me, but until he said it, I had never thought about it that way."

Instant-Grading Feature

In response, the company added more ways for students to jump around in their e-textbooks. From any homework problem, for instance, students can click to the relevant part of the text, or can jump to a part of their professor's recorded lecture that touched on that concept (if the professor makes use of that feature).

But the selling point to professors will most likely be the software's ability to grade student homework automatically. At a professor's request, the new e-textbooks can present a student with homework problems online, which are graded, with the scored work sent to both the student and the professor.

Jay Chakrapani, vice president for product development for McGraw-Hill Higher Education's digital group, said the system is designed to adapt to each student's progress, skipping to harder questions if the student aces the easy ones. "It's almost like a personal trainer or personal coach, constantly steering you to assessment items that probe you on the areas you're weak."

The company is urging professors to require the electronic textbooks for their courses, rather than leave it up to students whether they buy a printed book or an e-textbook. The company also sells a bundle that includes both the printed book and the e-book, because the company's research found that some students prefer print books to do their initial reading but electronic versions to review later. Of course, if students buy both, that also means even more revenue for the publishers. (For a Principals of Management textbook, the e-book and online tools cost $80, while a bundle that also includes the printed book costs $178.)

McGraw-Hill did not design its own lecture-capture software but instead has incorporated existing software made by Tegrity.

Other textbook publishers are offering new features in their digital products as well. E-textbooks sold through CourseSmart, a company started in 2007 by a group of textbook publishers, allow students to e-mail parts of the book to their friends (with their notes attached), or to read the complete text on their iPhone. E-textbooks published by Flat World Knowledge, meanwhile, let professors customize the textbook by adding their own chapters or making changes to the text for the edition offered to their students.

Is it possible that publishers could start selling textbooks that replace the need for going to class altogether? Mr. Stanford said no, that a professor will always be a core part of the learning process. But as textbook companies continue to add multimedia and assessment tools, such a scenario does not seem as far-fetched.


1. jeff1 - September 08, 2009 at 08:53 am

Fancy bells and whistles are great as augmentation to courses. Learning and motivating students is not that simply accomplished via automated systems . . . it can be done . . . it is not easily done with the majority of students and that is unlikely to change even if we had truly revolutionary courseware improvements. People (students), with all due respect to Mr. Stanford's opinions, are much more complex and need the context that faculty can provide in the give and take of a lecture, seminar, studio, etc. environments where learning occurs (this can be done on-line for many subjects). Teaching and learning are inefficient and time consuming and difficult to measure . . . yet the model has worked well for hundreds of years.

2. wlgoffe - September 08, 2009 at 09:10 am

When designing a new approach to textbooks, rather than asking students what they want in a text, why not look to the cognitive sciences on how people learn?

3. theprez - September 08, 2009 at 06:00 pm

wlgoffe's comment betrays an assumption that McGraw-Hill didn't consult cognitive science in designing this approach. Jeff1 seems to assume that this tool can't be used as supplemental and was meant to be the primary learning strategy. Neither conclusion seems supported by what I read.

4. donbaker36 - September 09, 2009 at 01:17 am



5. gerrydarden - September 09, 2009 at 09:11 pm

The pricing strategy seems a little off. If MH is serious about moving consumers away from printed textbooks, wouldn't it make sense for the purchase of the bundle at $178 to be more economical than only purchasing the printed text at $80? I.e purchasing the bundle could be that same as purchasing two printed texts at $160 or introductory priced around $140. In this challeging economic times, students care about cost as much as, if not more than, convenience.

6. ellisr - September 14, 2009 at 12:12 pm

I expect that this move has far more to do with marketing and attempting to regain a share of the profit lost to the used textbook market than it has with education or pedagogy. As an added bonus it is perfect keeping with the current love afair with technology in education and the Pathagorean trend to abstract everthing to a simple numerical value...

Add Your Comment

Commenting is closed.

subscribe today

Get the insight you need for success in academe.