To the Editor:

I carefully read "Research at What Cost?" (July 27) with mounting regret and shock. As a human being, I am saddened by Shawn Wight's unnecessary death; as an academic, I am astonished that Ohio State University cares more about its reputation and finances than it does about the students entrusted to its nurturing; and as a climber, I am angered by the comments and analyses offered by participants and authorities.

Although I have never climbed in the Himalayas and would never dare to disagree with Peter H. Hackett's assessment of a physical problem that arises from or involves altitude sickness, I know from experience, observation, and reading (including Hackett's own works) that any form of altitude sickness is potentially fatal. Since the only cure ... is to retreat downward, it is simply unbelievable that -- after proceeding up at such breakneck speed -- Wight, upon exhibiting such severe and continual symptoms, was not immediately evacuated. ...

Robert Hauptman Professor of Learning Resources and Technology Services St. Cloud State University St. Cloud, Minn.

http://chronicle.com Section: The Chronicle Review Page: B22